Institute for Statecraft
.jpg){kind=small}
The Institute for Statecraft (IfS), formerly the Institute for Statecraft and Governance[1], is a UK deep state milieu founded in 2006 as a UK limited company[2]. After receiving UK charitable status in 2009, it has received millions of pounds from the UK FCO and commercial organisations, although its website stated that “We are totally independent and impartial, not dependent on funding from political or government agencies, industrial interests, or any other source which might call our impartiality into question.” [3] It was exposed in November 2018 by the Integrity Initiative leak as a UK deep faction obsessed by permanent war mentality promoting a new cold war against Russia. Name lists reveal it to be staffed largely by spooks and/or deep state operatives. Nominally the Integrity Initiative (II) is a separate group, started by the IfS, but the group's own publications have used the two names interchangably[4] and one member bemoaned a "Lack of clear messaging, are we IFS or are we II."[5] The IfS continues to operate as of 2020 and hired new staff in 2019, although with a lower profile.
Contents
Own words
We never lobby, but we do not shirk from advocating specific policy choices, spreading good practice and promoting reform in the face of complacency or vested interest.[6]
“We engage only very discreetly with governments, based entirely on trusted personal contacts, specifically to ensure that they do not come to see our work as a problem, and to try to influence them gently, as befits an independent NGO operation like ours”
Institute for Statecraft (2 November 2018) [7]
The group's website's about page stated in January 2019 (just before it was taken down) that the IfS was "an independent body dedicated to refreshing the practice of statecraft, to improving governance and to enhancing national security."[8] Its registration at the Scottish Charity Register stated that its objects were:
"(1) To advance education in the fields of governance and statecraft, and in particular focussing on the leadership, direction, management and administration of public and private institutions, major organisations and other bodies (whether incorporated or otherwise), and the skills needed by those in authority within such institutions, organisations or bodies to enable them to deal effectively with current and future challenges particularly in respect of security
(2) To advance human rights, conflict resolution and/or reconciliation and religious/racial/ethnic harmony, to promote equality and diversity, citizenship and community development, and to advance national and international security; and in particular through assisting governments (including emerging democracies and countries in transition) and other institutions, organisations or bodies (whether in the UK or abroad) to respond to the challenges posed by new developments in the world (whether social, political, economic or technological) and to develop and embed structures and institutions that reflect principles of best practice in governance and statecraft."[9]
Headquarters
The leaked documents reveal the group's de facto HQ as the basement of 2 Temple Place, the former London mansion of William Waldorf Astor. Craig Murray reports that "the rent is paid by the Ministry of Defence".[10]
Staff
When founded in November 2006 the Institute for Statecraft and Governance[11] had 3 directors:
- Chris Donnelly, a former adviser to figures including Margaret Thatcher and four secretaries general of NATO, he also appears to who appears to run the group for the UK deep state.[12]
- Daniel Lafayeedney (who resigned as a director on 2011-11-08, but who continued working with the group)[11]
- Lesley Simm (who resigned 2012-08-08)[11]
Tom Lloyd was head of security from 2007-2010. The incomplete IfS staff list (right) has mostly been derived from combining the leaked documents with archived copies of the list of IfS fellows from their own website.[13][14]
Many of the older members in particular have connections to NATO, the Atlantic Council, the UK Army and to multiple deep state milieux[15] or have held senior positions in the UK government,[16], UK Army[17], NATO[18], the Atlantic Council[19] or NGOs.[20] At least one, Audrius Butkevičius, has been convicted of fraud. The group includes previously known members of intelligence agencies (such as Guy Spindler and Harold Elletson), some from SGMI and many more with spooky profiles. Foreign spooks include Dmytro Kolomoiets.
Some are entrepreneurs working in the areas with special relevance to The Deep State, such as "anti-terrorism" or "anti-corruption". Martin Dubbey set up Harod Associates, which carried out Project Iris, an analysis of how social media influenced European public perceptions about the Skripal Affair, for which the company was paid £12,000 by the II. Others have had, or continue to have, senior responsibilities in the UK establishment.[21]
Projection
- Full article: Institute for Statecraft/Projection
- Full article: Institute for Statecraft/Projection
The leaked documents suggest that the group is imbued by what might be called the "permanent war mentality" of Chris "we are at war" Donnelly[22]. As such, it consists not only of profiteers but also of "true believers", keenly "Defending Democracy" Against [Russian] Disinformation" by any and all available means.
Activities
- Full article:
Institute for Statecraft/Activities
- Full article:
The group operates mostly in Europe, although it has a lot of connections to other deep state operatives and is represented in deep state milieux worldwide.[24] A study of the leaked documents underlines not only the permanent war mentality which pervades the group, but also the (generally only implicit) assumption that it is willing and able to exert covert influence over both governments and citizens, an observation strengthened by the number of group members who are either memebrs of intelligence agencies or have backgrounds in psychological warfare.
Private meetings
Several of the leaked documents are "trip reports", detailing progress at fairly tightly scheduled unofficial meetings of which no public records exist. One step up from these totally private meetings are Chatham House rule (i.e. off-the-record) meetings with other groups, which have continued after the II leak.
Public conferences
The II has organised both public conferences and taken part at other events. These not only provide a chance to boost "awareness" about the putative threat posed by Russia, but also to sound out people in the unofficial edge of conferences. Some contact reports have been leaked. MI6 member Harold Elletson chaired a series of conferences on "terrorism", sometimes with other known or suspected deep state operatives (Security and Defence Learning/2010, for example, included by Chris Donnelly and Jeff McCausland, both fellow IfS members).
Integrity Initiative
- Full article: Integrity Initiative
- Full article: Integrity Initiative
Quite a lot of the IfS' activity was carried out under the "Integrity Initiative" label, which carried the stated desire to fight "Russian Propaganda". The director Dan Kaszeta described the group in his "Notes for Israel" as “Not just a “think tank” offering yet another discussion forum but also a “do tank”.” [25] He added that "We have good contacts in government in UK and other governments (Argentina, Baltic States, Lithuania, etc.")[26]
The II organised secret "clusters" of like minded people who would follow instructions from London to promote a particular message (the first Integrity Initiative Leak includes a timeline of the groups efforts to interfere in the Spanish government's appointment of ). As with the IfS in general, a Russophobic perpetual war mentality appears to beset the II. One of the main criteria for inclusion in a "cluster" seems to be "awareness" of the "Russian threat". At least one of the documents makes explicit mention of the need to increase military spending. The leaked documents and the II/IfS publications make almost no mention of "peace".
Private businesses
At least 50 members have been business directors[27] and three pairs of IfS members have set up private businesses together[28]. Others have shared directorships on long established groups such as the Russo-British Chamber of Commerce. Some of the IfS directors set up a UK company named the "Council on Foreign Relations".
Influence
The group's influence appears to have been extensive.
Active Change Foundation
- Full article: Active Change Foundation
- Full article: Active Change Foundation
In 2003 Hanif Qadir, "former extremist"[29] and IfS senior associate fellow, founded the Active Change Foundation, which worked closely with the IfS on "de-radicalisation". At least 3 other Active Change Foundation directors were also members of the IfS: David Gilbertson, Daniel Lafayeedney and Chris Donnelly.
"War on Terror"
- Full article:
“War on Terror”
- Full article:
Qadir is one of many IfS members with a financial stake in the "War on Terror". Some are professional "terror experts"[30] others have written about "terrorism" for decades[31].
Harold Elletson chaired, Security and Defence Learning, a series of annual "counter-terrorism" conferences, some of which involved other IfS members[32] and one of which involved an attendee of Le Cercle. Some have set up companies in this area. Others are academics or journalists who address this area. In 2018 the IfS had a "programme to develop discernment education for children of 9 and upwards, to keep them safe on-line and to protect them from disinformation and radicalisation".[26]
Corporate Media
- Full article: Corporate Media/Deep state control
- Full article: Corporate Media/Deep state control
Several IfS members have been published in the BBC,[33] while others have worked for the BBC[34] and a leaked document| lists several BBC employees, another lists Helen Boaden, a former Director of BBC news. Another leaked document by Euan Grant wrote that the IfS has “particular links with the Times, Telegraph, Guardian and BBC TV and radio” but says that it needs to “strengthen” its relationship with the Mail.
EPIC (Ex Police in Industry and Commerce)
- Full article: EPIC
- Full article: EPIC
EPIC (Ex Police in Industry and Commerce) is a "business networking organisation", founded in 2011. As of 2020, all the original directors had resigned, leaving at least 2/4 remaining directors as IfS members. IfS members include senior policemen.[35]
Campaign for the North
- Full article: Campaign for the North
- Full article: Campaign for the North
The "Campaign for the North" was chaired by Harold Elletson, and its contributors and advisors included at least three other members of the Ifs (Chris Donnelly, David Gilbertson and Angela White).
"Anti corruption"
Keith Sargent led of the IfS' "Governance and Integrity Group" and was "a regular chairperson and speaker on an Anti-Corruption seminar programme at the International Centre for Parliamentary Studies."[36] Stewart Eldon worked as a Senior Adviser on Defence and Security Issues to Transparency International. A November 2018 IfS budget allocates over £12,000 for a plan "Through links with UK law enforcement and revenue organisations, anti corruption and development NGO's and journalistic organisations, [to] gain access to their European counterparts".[37] Senior associate fellows Mark Pyman and Philip Matthews also reported an interest in the areas of "anti-corruption".[38]
Exposure
- Full article: Institute for Statecraft/Exposure
- Full article:
The Institute for Statecraft attracted a lot of interest in late 2018 after the first Integrity Initiative/Leak, which contained documents from an (apparent)[39] child group, the "Integrity Initiative". This was revealed not as the apolitical a multi-million pound charity it purported to be, but what David Miller termed "a military-directed push"[40] towards a New Cold War with Russia. He noted that operational HQ was a London basement both close to and paid for[41] by the UK MoD.[42]
Cover up
- Full article: Institute for Statecraft/Cover up
- Full article: Institute for Statecraft/Cover up
After the first Integrity Initiative leak sparked interest by independent media, labour MP Chris Williamson went to investigate at their operational HQ in Temple. The image shown (right) is taken from a story by The Canary. Some names of IfS members were removed from their website after the leak.
On 22 January 2019, the Integrity Initiative "temporarily" deleted the entire contents of their website.[43] The Institute for Statecraft followed suit shortly afterwards. By 5 February 2019, the site content had been replaced by a coverpage which stated that "The website will be relaunched shortly. In the meantime, we expect to be able to publish an analysis of the hack and its significance in the near future." It also opened up the way to plausible deniability by claiming that some (unspecified) parts of the leaked data had been falsified.[44]
Media reporting
In March 2019 Sky News carried a brief article headlined What is the Institute for Statecraft thought to have been hacked by Russia? reported that "[t]he organisation, which describes itself as a think-tank and a do-tank, employs a small staff of about a dozen people. It also has about 90 Fellows, including a handful of individuals who have a background in British intelligence or the military so are experts in security and defence." It made no mention of the Integrity Initiative's member Simon Bracey-Lane working for the Bernie Sanders campaign or the smears against Jeremy Corbyn. It mentioned that the II "established a network in countries across Europe" but did not mention how it used that network to mount of a secretly coordinated social media campaign to prevent the appointment of Pedro Baños as Director of the Spanish Department of Homeland Security.[45]
Related Quotations
| Page | Quote | Author | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Integrity Initiative | “We've temporarily removed all content from our website, pending an investigation into the theft of data from the Institute for Statecraft and the Integrity Initiative. The website will be relaunched shortly. https://bit.ly/2sES9wM” | 22 January 2019 | |
| Greg Rowett | “spoke well and hit all the IfS points: peacetime mentality during war/Russian vocab all based on warfare/rate of change in society dramatic/need for universal glossary. Algorithms key – we need to start gaming these algorithms and put pressure onto the companies hosting these disinformation campaigns. Deliver message that we're willing and able to push back.” | Simon Bracey-Lane Greg Rowett | December 2017 |
| University of Leicester | ““Following discussions in Leicester and London, the School of History, Politics and International Relations has concluded a Memorandum of Understanding with the Institute for Statecraft, an independent body dedicated to refreshing the practice of statecraft, improving governance and enhancing national security. Head of School, Dr George Lewis, said “This development is yet another example of the skill and standing of colleagues involved in our Distance Learning programmes, and is further recognition of the School's strengths in teaching, research and research-led teaching in the field of international politics and security.” In warmly welcoming the collaboration, Chris Donnelly and Dan Lafayeedney, the founding (sic)<a href="#cite_note-4">[4]</a> co-Directors of the Institute for Statecraft, stated that “it recognises the significant standing in which the Institute is held internationally by policy makers and decision takers of governments, development and security agencies, and private sector clients, and it reflects the unique blend of practice and authoritative research that the Institute’s Fellows and Associates are able to contribute”. Building upon the University’s links with UNITAR and both party’s links with NATO, this Memorandum of Understanding demonstrates the potential for the University of Leicester and the Institute for Statecraft to collaborate, share experience and develop opportunities that will have a direct impact on national and international policy-making.” | Unknown | December 2018 |
| Zinc Network | “Bringing together organisations including Zinc Network, the Institute for Statecraft, Aktis Strategy, Bellingcat, DFR Lab, the Media Diversity Institute, Toro Risk Solutions and Ecorys, our Consortium combines recognised market leaders in understanding, monitoring, and countering Kremlin-backed disinformation... This ecosystem of credible voices will continue to grow, exposing the actors and networks behind Kremlin-backed disinformation, reducing unwitting multipliers of disinformation, and building resilience amongst key target audiences across Europe.
We will mobilise a Network Hub based in London, led by an experienced Project Director, consisting of an agile team with core competencies augmented by a wider pool of vetted experts. Our approach is highly localised, based around regional clusters of actors who can collaborate to effectively undermine the disinformation ecosystem in their respective areas and engage audiences most vulnerable to disinformation... It is a highly complex project involving coordination of many independent actors, and thus risk must be carefully managed and risk profiles constantly adapted, serving as the basis for all activity. The approach we propose is based on the identification, monitoring and management of risks as they materialise, allowing members to continue taking smart risks as they increase the scale and impact of their activities.” |
Group
| Group | Start | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Integrity Initiative | 2015 | "Military-directed" "extremely shady covert disinformation and anti-democratic deep state outfit" that promotes Russophobic propaganda. Exposed by a set of 7 caches of documents, posted online. Later deleted its website. |
Employees on Wikispooks
| Employee | Job | Appointed | End | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eduard Abrahamyan | Senior Associate Fellow | April 2019 | ||
| James Austin | Research Fellow | March 2017 | November 2017 | |
| James Austin | Project Support officer | July 2018 | July 2019 | |
| Francis Ghilès | As of February 2020 | |||
| Maria de Goeij | Academic | April 2018 | Deleted this piece of history from her LinkedIn. Now called "thinktank" and having no resignation date. | |
| Tom Lloyd | Head of Security | 2007 | 2010 | |
| John Lough | Senior Research Fellow | 2008 | ||
| Johanna Möhring | Academic | November 2013 | Also programme director | |
| Ben Nimmo | 2015 | |||
| Chris Scheurweghs | Senior fellow | January 2016 |
Known members
109 of the 137 of the members already have pages here:
| Member | Description |
|---|---|
| Kevin Abraham | Institute for Statecraft businessman |
| Eduard Abrahamyan | Institute for Statecraft, whose PhD supervisor was also a Institute for Statecraft member. |
| Jack Agazarian | Institute for Statecraft businessman whose name was gone by 10 January 2019. |
| Jamal Al-Tahat | Senior fellow of the Institute for Statecraft who was paid £1000 for setting up Integrity Jordan. |
| Kamal Alam | Fellow of the Institute for Statecraft, |
| Diane Allen | One of the first women in the Sandhurst, an Institute for Statecraft senior spook with DV (developed vetting) |
| David Allfrey | Former head of the UK Army's head of recruitment strategy, Institute for Statecraft |
| Josh Arnold-Foster | Member of the Institute for Statecraft. Posts include "special adviser" to the UK defence secretary. |
| Barrie Axford | UK Academic specialist "linking universities into the [Institute for Statecraft] network" |
| Anne Bader | Senior Associate Fellow of the Institute for Statecraft |
| Quique Badia-Masoni | Spanish journalist member of the Integrity Initiative and the Institute for Statecraft. |
| Samantha de Bendern | UK deep state-connected polyglot "international civil servant" with a masters degree in Wealth Management, fellow of the Institute for Statecraft, associate fellow of Chatham House |
| William Bortrick | Institute for Statecraft senior fellow whose name was removed from their website before 10 January 2019. Drafted a letter which claimed that Charles Windsor was "100% behind" a cash for citizenship and CBE case. |
| Simon Bracey-Lane | A "highly improbable left wing firebrand" who worked for the Institute for Statecraft and whom they denied was a spook. |
| Robin Brims | Major General, fellow of the Institute for Statecraft |
| Audrius Butkevičius | Lithuanian politician and fellow of the Institute for Statecraft |
| Nicholas Chance | On the advisory Board of the Institute of Statecraft, an affiliation he continued to display in January 2020 |
| David Clark | Senior fellow and project director at the Institute for Statecraft. UK MP. |
| Sean Cronin | A little known spook and member of the Institute for Statecraft |
| Constance Cunningham | Institute for Statecraft, Active Change Foundation |
| Oleksandr Danylyuk | Ukrainian member of the Institute for Statecraft |
| Kingsley Donaldson | "Senior Associate Fellow" of the Institute for Statecraft. His specialism was listed as "Security Sector Reform, Conflict Resolution". |
| Robert Dover | UK academic with a special interest in UK/Western intelligence agencies. Institute for Statecraft, as is at least one of his graduate students. His name had been removed from the IfS website by 10 January 2019. |
| Martin Dubbey | A member of the Institute for Statecraft with years of experience involving "corruption enquiries at the highest level". |
| Martin Edmonds | Senior Associate Fellow of the Institute for Statecraft whose name was removed after the Integrity Initiative Leak |
| Stewart Eldon | UK DSO interested in "counter-corruption" and "National Security". Former UK/Permanent Representative to the North Atlantic Council, Institute for Statecraft |
| Harold Elletson | MI6, MP, Integrity Initiative, New Society Foundation |
| Dair Farrar-Hockley | A retired Major General who joined the Institute for Statecraft. |
| Perry Fawcett | UK businessman, ex-policeman, and member of the Institute for Statecraft |
| Irene Martínez Fernández | Joined the Institute for Statecraft as an associate researcher in July 2019 |
| Maria Luisa Fichera | Former member of the Institute for Statecraft, worked at the International Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology |
| Alexander Finnen | Spooky UK deep state operative, Chris Donnelly's "right hand man" |
| Anthony Fitzherbert | Institute for Statecraft member and former FAO Programme manager in Afghanistan who co-authored research on crop yields. |
| Mark Galeotti | Institute for Statecraft propagandist |
| Babak Ganji | "Strategic analysis education, with the job description as "Russia-MENA influence and infowar strategy and tactics" at the Institute for Statecraft |
| Francis Ghilès | Trilingual journalist who has been published since the 1990s on topics including "terrorism". He wrote in 2016 that "we are nowhere close to the end of the War on Terror". A member of the Institute for Statecraft. |
| David Gilbertson | UK policeman who joined the Institute for Statecraft in his returement. Director of the Active Change Foundation from 2015-2017 |
| Keir Giles | Russophobic UK deep state operative, member of Integrity Initiative. |
| Maria de Goeij | Integrity Initiative/Institute for Statecraft polyglot |
| Roger Golland | UK Diplomat and IfS member |
| David Gordon-Macleod | UK deep state connected diplomat |
| Euan Grant | Spooky journalist/propagandist who worked for the Integrity Initiative interested in financial fraud. "His main forte is thinking strategically and has experience working in many countries around the world." |
| Glen Grant | 37 year military career. Institute for Statecraft senior fellow. "His key work in the last twenty years has been delivering reform and change for defence and security organisations in Europe." |
| Rafael Gude | Little known member of the Institute for Statecraft. |
| Tom Hardie-Forsyth | A member of the Institute for Statecraft who worked through Chatham House as a senior advisor to the Kurdistan Regional Government |
| Amalyah Hart | A fellow of the Institute for Statecraft whose speciality was listed as "Hybrid Warfare, Indo-Pacific Region" when the group took down their website |
| Harry Hart | Institute for Statecraft director who resigned after the Integrity Initiative leak. Serial company director, son of a spooky adviser to Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s. |
| Charlie Hatton | "Brand Development Consultant", was Senior Programme Manager of the Integrity Initiative |
| Jon Hazel | Little known SGMI, Institute for Statecraft operative |
| Chris Hernon | Integrity Initiative |
| ... further results | |
Events Planned
| Event | Start | End | Location(s) | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reframing Russia | 1 June 2017 | 31 May 2020 | University of Manchester | An IfS/II discussed project about "The RT Challenge" which was publicly launched in 2019, not under the II/IfS name. |
| Russia’s Strategy on NATO'S Eastern and Southern Flanks | 27 January 2017 09:30:00 | 27 January 2017 16:30:00 | Barcelona Centre for International Affairs | A CIDOB/The Institute for Statecraft/NATO meeting |
| Strengthening Europe's 'soft' and 'hard' defence | 25 March 2019 13:00:00 | 25 March 2019 17:00:00 | Netherlands The Hague Clingendael Institute | Chatham House rule meeting with organised by the Institute for Statecraft and the Clingendael Institute. |
Sponsors
| Event | Description |
|---|---|
| Answering Russia's Strategic Narratives | Invitation only one day event organised by The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies, sponsored by The Institute for Statecraft, about "Russian propaganda" |
| WhistleblowersUK | UK group chaired since November 2015 by the former Institute for Statecraft head of security, Tom Lloyd. |
Related Documents
| Title | Type | Publication date | Author(s) | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Document:Britain didn’t vote Labour just to get a new iron chancellor | Article | 4 August 2024 | William Keegan | The economic damage wrought by Brexit continues. Our investment and growth prospects would benefit enormously if Starmer and Reeves abandoned this policy of “no return to the customs union, single market or freedom of movement”. I repeat what I have said before: the Labour manifesto commits it to removing unnecessary barriers to trade. But Brexit is the most formidable barrier of all! |
| Document:Speaking notes for meetings in Israel | speaking notes | June 2018 | Dan Kaszeta | Institute for Statecraft wants to build a relationship with the Israeli government |
| Document:The Institute for Statecraft Expert Team v 3 | name list | 13 December 2018 | Chris Donnelly | biographies of core team members with lots of obscure but interesting former and present employers |
Rating
20 April 2019 Robin An overview of this organ of the UK Deep stateA good start for understanding this group which appears to be a UK Deep state effort to promote Russophobia and attempting to kick of a New Cold War.
References
- ↑ https://www.companieslist.co.uk/prev/SC312442-the-institute-for-statecraft-and-governance
- ↑ http://anoniem.org/?https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/SC312442/filing-history
- ↑ http://archive.today/2018.12.27-160140/https://www.statecraft.org.uk/ethical-charter , 28 December 2018
- ↑ http://archive.today/2020.01.26-153746/https://medium.com/@instituteforstatecraft/russian-media-in-germany-independent-journalism-or-political-instrument-bafe4f6f6c6b
- ↑ Integrity Initiative/Leak/4
- ↑ http://archive.today/2018.12.27-160140/https://www.statecraft.org.uk/ethical-charter
- ↑ Document:Top 3 deliverables/achievements of phase 1
- ↑ https://anoniem.org?https://www.statecraft.org.uk/about-us
- ↑ https://www.oscr.org.uk/search/charity-details?number=SC040870
- ↑ a b https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2018/12/british-security-service-infiltration-the-integrity-initiative-and-the-institute-for-statecraft/
- ↑ a b c http://www.checkcompany.co.uk/company/SC312442/THE-INSTITUTE-FOR-STATECRAFT
- ↑ https://www.ukcolumn.org/article/integrity-initiative-look-deep-state
- ↑ http://archive.today/2019.01.08-010239/https://www.statecraft.org.uk/governance
- ↑ http://archive.today/2019.01.10-215210/https://www.statecraft.org.uk/fellows
- ↑ Keir Giles is a member of Chatham House and the Brookings Institute
- ↑ David Clark was Minister for the Cabinet Office and Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster
- ↑ Major General Jonathan Shaw
- ↑ Ben Nimmo was NATO Press officer
- ↑ Stewart Eldon was the UK Permanent Representative to the North Atlantic Council and UK Deputy Permanent Representative to the UN
- ↑ Tom Lloyd chaired WhistleblowersUK.
- ↑ Elaine Birch Ruffell "Led assessment & disruption of narcotic trafficking from Afghanistan to Europe"
- ↑ Document:Establishing a modern perspective - Nation-State vs Network State
- ↑ Chris Donnelly, Maria de Goeij, Johanna Moehring, Alan Riley
- ↑ For example, the Integrity Initiative had Clusters in Australia, the US and Jordan
- ↑ Document:Speaking notes for meetings in Israel
- ↑ a b Document:Speaking notes for meetings in Israel
- ↑ Kevin Abraham, Jack Agazarian, David Allfrey, Samantha de Bendern, William Bortrick, Nicholas Chance, Oleksandr Danylyuk, Kingsley Donaldson, Robert Dover, Martin Dubbey, Stewart Eldon, Harold Elletson, Dair Farrar-Hockley, Perry Fawcett, Alexander Finnen, Anthony Fitzherbert, Mark Galeotti, Francis Ghilès, David Gilbertson, Roger Golland, David Gordon-Macleod, Harry Hart, Henry Hogger, Graham Jeal, Harry Lawson Johnston, Stephen Jolly, Ren Kapur, Dan Kaszeta, Shima Keene, Daniel Lafayeedney, Jean-Louis Lafayeedney, Tom Lloyd, John Lough, Jahan Mahmood, Philip Matthews, Oliver McTernan, Piroska Nagy-Mohacsi, Chris Nel, Hanif Qadir, Alan Riley, Elaine Birch Ruffell, Raheem Shapi, Andrew Shortland, Lesley Simm, Guy Spindler, Celia Szusterman, Yusuf Tai, Richard Titley, Joseph Walker-Cousins, Andy Wood
- ↑ Temple Strategic Advisory Ltd (Samantha de Bendern and Alan Riley), Astutus Intelligence (Philip Matthews and Martin Dubbey), Borley Investments (Harry Hart and, briefly, Jack Agazarian)
- ↑ https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-29872054
- ↑ Dan Kaszeta, Shima Keene, Fatima Lahnait, Hanif Qadir, Lesley Simm, Richard Titley, Jason Wiseman
- ↑ Francis Ghilès
- ↑ Security and Defence Learning/2010
- ↑ Jamal Al-Tahat, Chris Donnelly, Keir Giles, Francis Ghilès, Dan Kaszeta, Louise Sherwood, Hew Strachan
- ↑ Stephen Dalziel, Chris Hernon
- ↑ Perry Fawcett, David Gilbertson, Tom Lloyd
- ↑ https://www2.le.ac.uk/departments/criminology/documents/building-security-and-justice-in-post-conflict-environments-a-reader
- ↑ Document:Integrity_Initiative_Budget_for_the_12_months_ending_31_March_2019
- ↑ http://archive.today/2018.03.03-165732/http://www.statecraft.org.uk/fellows
- ↑ The distinction between the two groups seems in practice to be rather moot
- ↑ https://www.mintpressnews.com/the-integrity-initiative-and-the-uks-scandalous-information-war/253014/
- ↑ https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2018/12/british-security-service-infiltration-the-integrity-initiative-and-the-institute-for-statecraft/
- ↑ https://www.ukcolumn.org/article/integrity-initiative-look-deep-state
- ↑ https://www.rt.com/news/449451-integrity-initiative-deletes-content/
- ↑ http://web.archive.org/web/20190205061422/https://www.statecraft.org.uk/
- ↑ https://news.sky.com/story/what-is-the-institute-for-statecraft-thought-to-have-been-hacked-by-russia-11657071
