Climate change

"Climate change"  (“Disaster”,  Ideology,  Enemy image,  Population control,  Environmentalism)
Interest of	• "Smart city" • Martin Armstrong • David Attenborough • Colette Pichon Battle • Rosina Bierbaum • Bilderberg/1989 • Bilderberg/2019 • Jane Burston • Dennis Bushnell • COP26 • COP27 • Club of Rome • Committee of 300 • Competitive Enterprise Institute • Counter Currents • Peter Daszak • William Engdahl • Extinction Rebellion • Frontiers of Freedom • George C. Marshall Institute • Al Gore • Green Industrial Revolution • David Grimes • IPCC • James Inhofe • Jay Inslee • Jerm Warfare • Arshad Khan • David Lewis • Richard Lindzen • Graeme Maxton • Sonia Medina • Michael Oppenheimer • Lavanya Rajamani • S. Ichtiaque Rasool • David de Rothschild • Greg Rowett • Sierra Club • Nicholas Stern • Vava Tampa • The Great Reset • Greta Thunberg • Dale Vince
Subpage(s)	•"Climate change/Flood" •"Climate change/Hurricane" •Climate change/Dissident •Climate change/Legislation •Climate change/Preparation
the dogma that rise in CO2 levels correspond to a (as of yet non-significant) rise in temperature and that the world is ahead of an apocalyptic disaster

Climate change, formerly known as global warming, formerly known as global cooling is the tautology that climate changes. The theory holds that it is "man made" and thus implies that "the real enemy is humanity itself" (Club of Rome) by assuming the occurrence of a natural disaster due to CO₂ production. However, CO₂ levels have been higher during ice ages and temperatures are below the average of past 1000 years.

Measurements supporting warming of 1-2 degrees have been manipulated by preferring stations in cities over time, where temperature is 2-4 degrees higher than in nature. The theory seems plausible because burning of fossil fuels results in toxic gas emissions like CO, NO2, etc, and smoke particles. "Carbon taxes" seem to equate the gas CO₂ with carbon, which is misleading.

Throughout the years dissenting scientists have raised their voice and argued for alternative explanations In the political sphere, the administration of Donald Trump has cast doubt on climate change, as has the lobby of oil exporting countries historically. Most of the documents at the foot of this article explain the reality of climate change differently as it is presented by corporate media.

“we came up with the idea that ... global warming ... and the like, would fit the bill.”
Club of Rome,  Alexander King,  Bertrand Schneider (1993) 
The First Global Revolution, 1973 edition

Official narrative

The website https://showyourstripes.info shows climate data from 1901 (left) up to 2018 (right), as a simple set of red/blue stripes. This is their 'global' image, indicating that in spite of considerable year to year variation, in aggregate, global temperatures are rising.

Wikipedia covers it extensively. The official narrative holds that:

• the post-industrial atmospheric CO₂ concentration increase is directly a result of fossil fuel burning
• the post-industrial increase in atmospheric CO₂ concentration causes a greenhouse warming
• a measurable global mean surface warming has occurred in the post-industrial period
• anthropogenic global warming drives “climate chaos” and produces extreme weather events

The narrative also holds that for decades, scientists who researched climate change were marginalized, while big oil made sure climate warnings were kept out of corporate media. While it is true some big oil interests have financed climate change skeptics and right-wing politicians, deep state leaders, especially the circle around David Rockefeller, have supported and heavily promoted the idea of anthropogenic climate change at least since the late 1960s. A study of corporate media over the years will show that climate change has not been a marginalized subject, but that dire warnings have been given prime coverage, and since the 2000s, have been totally dominant.

Selected peak records

Observed average temperatures have been rising, as the Greenhouse Effect would predict (source: unknown, possibly WP). Image depicts not temperature but grossly stretched deviance from an imaginary "normality", inconsistent with the higher 300-year-average from public records (London, Berlin Tempelhof)

The US’s largest water reservoir, Lake Mead, was reported in 2016 as having "the lowest level since it was filled in the 1930s". The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration declared March 2016 was the warmest March since records began in 1880.

Extreme weather events

The phrase "climate change" is used in preference to "global warming" since current predictions^{[By whom?]} highlight the instability in the world's climate, the amplification of more extreme weather events of all kinds, such as: wind, temperature, atmospheric pressure, droughts, flash floods, etc.

Melting polar ice caps (omittung the inverse trend at the other pole)

20 Year IMBIE Study

What if it's a big hoax and we create a better world for nothing?

A study from 2012 that was analyzing satellite data starting from 1992 came to conclude that the polar ice sheets are melting at an increased pace. According to one of the authors of the study, Andrew Shepherd: "It's the first time all the people who have estimated changes in the size of the Antarctic and Greenland ice sheets using satellites over the past 20 years have got together to produce a single result,". The study found that ice melting from Antarctica and Greenland has contributed 20% to the overall sea level rising in that same period. Two thirds are coming from Greenland even while it has only one tenth of the size of Antarctica, probably due to its position closer to the equator and warmer air. The rest of the sea level rising is attributed to thermal expansion of a warming ocean, melting of mountain glaciers, small Arctic ice caps and groundwater mining. The Antarctic is distinguished between east and west. Since the west's glaciers are at sea level, the warming of the seawater is accelerating the melting. The east is mostly above sea level and thanks to appropriate temperatures there is snowfall and the ice sheet actually growing.

25 Year IMBIE Study

The 2018 update of the study found the conclusion from five years before confirmed and observed a threefold increase in ice loss since 2012. It is generally acknowledged that the ice loss in Antarctica is more severe in areas where there is direct contact with the ocean. In 2017 it was reported that in the west of Antarctica NASA discovered a "mantle plume" (where magma exists) which could be a cause of the ice melting in the region today.

IMBIE - Ice Sheet Mass Balance Inter-Comparison Exercise

Underwater volcanoes

75% of the world’s volcanic activity is under the oceans water. They are producing around three quarters of the year’s output of magma. Their role in the warming of the ocean is a field of research, but not yet understood. However, it is possible that volcanic activity has a far greater influence on ice melting in the Antarctic region as currently suspected.

Problems

Long term data

past 3000 years, today=0 depicted left. Source: Zbigniew Jaworowski, M.D., Ph.D., D.Sc., "Solar Cycles, Not CO², Determine Climate"

Climate change sceptics

Denis Rancourt points out that if CO₂ acts like a mirror (reflecting energy back to the earth) it must be assumed that it acts like a one-way mirror - which is highly unlikely. Martin Armstrong is of the opinion that the current arguments around climate change, as told by activists like Thunberg, Gore and Gates are engineered to fit a certain "green" agenda and are amplified by a subservient press. He cites a April 1975, Newsweek magazine article as one of the last examples that the global press wanted to make the population believe that a new ice age is coming. |subjects= |text=I argue that by far the most destructive force on the planet is power-driven financiers and profit-driven corporations and their cartels backed by military might; and that the global warming myth is a red herring that contributes to hiding this truth. In my opinion, activists who, using any justification, feed the global warming myth have effectively been co-opted, or at best neutralized. |authors=Denis G. Rancourt |source_URL=http://activistteacher.blogspot.com/2007/02/global-warming-truth-or-dare.html }}

Fear mongering

A claim made in 1989 for the year 2000.

Climate alarmists have been using language to instill fear in an unsuspecting population since at least the 1970s. Some critics argue therefore that what is playing out with the hype around climate change, which is perpetuated by groups like Fridays for Future, is linked to other elite ideas like the The Great Reset.

Medieval Climate Optimum

IPCC document, "Observed Climate Variations and Change".

The Medieval Climate Optimum was an unusually warm period in history lasting from about the 10th century to about the 14th century. During this time wine grapes were grown in Europe up to 300 miles (~480 KM) north of their present northerly growing limit.

"IPCC documents up to at least 1995 had faithfully depicted the existence of both the Medieval Warm Period and Little Ice Age ... The Medieval Warm Period and subsequent Little Ice Age - which followed hard on the heels of the Roman Warm Period and Dark Ages Cold Period (McDermott et al., 2001) - were long considered to be classic examples of the warm and cold phases of a millennial-scale climate oscillation that has reverberated seemingly endlessly throughout glacial and interglacial periods alike (Oppo et al., 1998; McManus et al., 1999), as well as across the early Pleistocene (Raymo et al., 1998)."

The Arctic Oscillation (AO) refers to an atmospheric circulation pattern over the mid-to-high latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere. It can have a strong influence on weather and climate in major population centers in North America, Europe, and Asia, especially during winter.

Climategate

Full article: Climategate

In 2009 Wikileaks published <1000 emails from the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) scientists.

Several referenced emails contain joking remarks about how they massaged statistics, i.e.

• truncating the temperature and time axis on diagrams
• omitting data from measurement stations that were "too cold to be included"
• failing to mention contradicting information, i.e.
  • polar ice data from Patagonia (the other pole, where ice is increasing)
  • failing to report standard deviations or volatility measures
  • failing to mention conflicts of interest, explicit joking about easy available grants and salaries

The dubious funding of IPCC was also discussed in the Climategate leak of emails. A condensed version is found on WS: Climategate E-mails.

Russia's new icebreakers

Russia has more than a century of experience in building icebreakers and is operating the biggest fleet historically. While commercially-controlled media reporting mentions Russia's investment in new vehicles that do surpass the last generation, some articles make the connection to "global warming", or "climate change" (basically implying that these icebreakers are still needed, not in the sense that the ice is growing, but the opposite). However, some events indicate that the ice may still not be in such a distinct retreat and the investment in a new class of ships is justified:

• in 2019 a research-vessel/icebreaker got stuck in July in ice that was thicker than they expected
• in 2021 dozens of ships (who were assured of good weather) were pinned down as the ice was freezing early

Preparations

Full article: Climate_change/Preparation

Amidst the COVID-19/Lockdown the WEF announced on its website a series of articles suggesting that the "pandemic" serves as preparation for an even greater disaster, namely climate change. The Club of Rome promotes the view that "population explosion" is to be blamed, at least since the 1970s when the IPCC was formed.

Doing the right thing for the wrong reasons?

What kind of threat is a human for the Earth? - George Carlin - 1992

As the Wizards of Money (i.e. part 21) points out repeatedly, in the financial system risk management got out of hand. The system got unstable and therefore unsustainable for society. Climate change assumes higher risks in the future and may force the financial system and global cartels (TNCs) through reinsurance companies, who have the muscle, to assume more responsibility. If forced to pay higher insurance prices for losses (due to excessive gambling) this means reduced profit margins for TNCs, but also reduced systemic risk for the general public.

"Smithy" interviews a reinsurance expert of Munich Re, who confirms (as of 2003) that CEOs are pressured to insure against higher risks (because of assumed future "climate changes"). These may be real, but the causal connection to human activity is in any case hard to prove, as the earth's climate constitutes a complex, chaotic system with more than one input stream. Nevertheless reduced risk taking might be a healthy thing to do.

 

Examples

Page name	Description
Agenda 2030	A UN plan to achieve what they term "sustainable development" by 2030.
Green Industrial Revolution	preventing climate change?

 

Related Quotations

Page	Quote	Author	Date
"Overpopulation"	“Overpopulation and the overreliance on irrigation was a major factor in making the Maya vulnerable to failure: the trigger event of their collapse appears to have been a long drought beginning about 840 A.D. (communication of V. Scarborough, an archaelogist (sic!) from the University of Cincinnati [90]). Among many factors, such as war and plagues, that contributed to many of the collapses of ancient societies, there seem to be two main causes: too many people and too little fresh water. As a consequence, the civilization became vulnerable to environmental stress, for instance, a prolonged drought or a change in climate [90]. The societies themselves appear to have contributed to their own demise by encouraging growth of their population to levels that carried the seeds of their own decline through overexploitation of the land (communication of C. Scarre, an archaelogist (sic!) from the Cambridge University in England [90]). Similarly, the Akkadian empire in Mesopotamia, the Old Kingdom of Egypt, the Indus Valley civilization in India, and early societies in Palestine, Greece, and Crete all collapsed in a catastrophic drought and cooling of the atmosphere between 2300 and 2200 B.C.”	Didier Sornette	2003
Bilderberg/1989	“The observed increase in global mean temperature has been neither monotonic with time nor uniform over the globe as has been the increase of greenhouse gases. This situation calls into question the validity of isolating the greenhouse effect as the only cause of the recent temperature increase. A second uncertainty stems from the knowledge that the Earth has gone through major perturbations in temperature and climate in the past and continues to go through seasonal and cyclical changes (Figures 8, 9). How much if any of the recent changes then are just part of a long term trend is not known.”		1989
George Carlin	“The planet is fine. The people are fucked. Because everyone is trying to save the planet. The planet doesn’t need that. The planet will take care of itself. People are selfish. And that's what they're doing is trying to save the planet for themselves to have a nicer place to live. They don't care about the planet in theory. They just care about having a comfortable place. And these people with the fires and the floods and everything, they overbuild, they put nature to the test and they get what's coming to them. That's what I say. That's what's happening, and I can't wait for the sea levels to rise. I can't wait for some of these cities to disappear. There are places that are going to go away. The map is going to change and that's because — people think nature is outside of them. They don't take into them the idea that we are part of it. They say, "oh, we're going for a nature walk. We're going to the country because we like nature." Nature is in here. [points to chest] And if you're in tune with it, like the Indians, the Hopis, especially, the balance of life, the balance, the harmony of nature, if you understand that, you don't overbuild. You don’t do all this moron stuff.”	George Carlin
George Carlin	“We're so self-important. So self-important. Everybody's going to save something now. "Save the trees, save the bees, save the whales, save those snails." And the greatest arrogance of all: "save the planet." What? Are these fucking people kidding me? Save the planet, we don't even know how to take care of ourselves yet! We don't care for one another, we're gonna save the fucking planet? I'm getting tired of that shit. I'm tired of fucking Earth Day. I'm tired of these self-righteous environmentalists, these white, bourgeois liberals who think the only thing wrong with this country is that there aren't enough bicycle paths. People trying to make the world safe for their Volvos. Besides, environmentalists don't give a shit about the planet. Not in the abstract, they don't. You know what they're interested in? A clean place to live. Their own habitat. They're worried that someday in the future they might be personally inconvenienced. Narrow, unenlightened self-interest doesn't impress me. The planet has been through a lot worse than us. Been through earthquakes, volcanoes, plate tectonics, continental drift, solar flares, sunspots, magnetic storms, the magnetic reversal of the poles … hundreds of thousands of years of bombardment by comets and asteroids and meteors, worldwide floods, tidal waves, worldwide fires, erosion, cosmic rays, recurring ice ages … And we think some plastic bags and some aluminum cans are going to make a difference? The planet isn't going anywhere. WE are!”	George Carlin
Climate change/Preparation	“Similarly, the Akkadian empire in Mesopotamia, the Old Kingdom of Egypt, the Indus Valley civilization in India, and early societies in Palestine, Greece, and Crete all collapsed in a catastrophic drought and cooling of the atmosphere between 2300 and 2200 B.C.”	Didier Sornette	2003
Club of Rome	“In searching for a common enemy against whom we can unite, we came up with the idea that pollution, the threat of global warming, water shortages, famine and the like, would fit the bill. In their totality and their interactions these phenomena do constitute a common threat which must be confronted by everyone together. But in designating these dangers as the enemy, we fall into the trap, which we have already warned readers about, namely mistaking symptoms for causes. All these dangers are caused by human intervention in natural processes, and it is only through changed attitudes and behaviour that they can be overcome. The real enemy then is humanity itself.”	Alexander King Club of Rome Bertrand Schneider	1993
David Foreman	“An Ice Age is coming and I welcome it as much-needed changing. I see no solution to our ruination of earth except for a drastic reduction of the human population.”	David Foreman
Andrei Fursov	“Attali analyzes history and present-day events in the light of the change of Merchant orders. The contemporary one — the ninth — is going through an extremely acute crisis, which will end with the demise of Pax Americana. Then a furcation will occur. In Attali’s view, either world government will be established at once or it will emerge as a result of a three-move process of the 2020-2060s: hyperempire (market without democracy), hyperconflict and hyperdemocracy with a supranational government at its head. The analysis of Attali’s works shows that he expresses the interests of the top of the world capitalist class that adheres to ultra-globalist positions and works for the subversion of the sovereignty of nation-states. The terminology used by Attali, particularly “sustainable development” / “sustainable growth” (in reality, it is the combination of deindustrialization, depopulation and ecologism), indicates his neo-Malthusian and neo-colonialist preferences. “Sustainable development” is a metaphor of the new world order (à la Orwell’s Newspeak), which is nothing more than control over resources (including information ones) and human behaviour (psychosphere). The main thing in this order is the preservation of power, property and privileges of the world’s elite whose ideological representative Attali is.”	Andrei Fursov	2014
Global Commission for Post-Pandemic Policy	“The development in less than a year of several highly effective vaccines against COVID-19 was hailed as a "miracle" by some. The reality is more mundane. It was a real-world example of what can be achieved when politicians, policymakers, the private sector and scientists focus on mobilising the funds, resources and talents necessary to tackle a specific, highly motivating problem. Why then, should the human race not be trying to replicate the vaccine breakthrough to tackle the even greater threat of climate change?”	Luke Lythgoe	9 July 2021
IPCC	“The globe is warming because of increasing greenhouse gas emissions No evidence is presented to justify this conclusion. There are “projections” of computer models but these are not predictions, they are merely the results of assumptions made in the model. No “projected” result has ever been successfully related to an actual change in the climate.”	Vincent Richard Gray
International Maritime Organization	“Despite being responsible for close to 3% of global greenhouse gas emissions, the shipping sector remains outside of the UN Paris Agreement on climate. It has achieved this through corporate capture of the International Maritime Organization”
Boris Johnson	“How the hell can we witter on about tackling global warming, and reducing consumption, when we are continuing to add so relentlessly to the number of consumers? The answer is politics, and political cowardice.”	Boris Johnson	25 October 2007
Charles Mountbatten-Windsor	“We've so degraded natural systems, eco-systems, biodiversity, that it's becoming increasingly impossible for nature to sustain us...At the moment it's all take, take. Now we've reached the situation where we really need four planets like earth to survive or provide enough for everybody....So what do we do? Without doubt we must now put ourselves on a war-like footing, approaching our action from the perspective of a military-style campaign. That way, working together we can combat this most grave and urgent challenge. If we have the resolve to shift our trajectory we must start now, by bringing forward our net zero target.”	Charles Mountbatten-Windsor	2020
Klaus Schwab	“[...] the pandemic represents a rare but narrow window of opportunity to reflect, reimagine, and reset our world to create a healthier, more equitable, and more prosperous future.”	Klaus Schwab	3 June 2020
Dale Vince	“Anyone who says the climate crisis is not happening or it's not man-made, honestly, I think they're a dangerous fool, because it's like denying the Holocaust happened”	Dale Vince	29 June 2023

 

Related Documents

Title	Type	Publication date	Author(s)	Description
Document:Climate stupidity and human survival	article	22 May 2015	Denis Rancourt	A broad-canvass look at the context of allegedly catastrophic, CO2-induced, anthropogenic global warming.
Document:Global Warming: Truth or Dare?	article		Denis Rancourt
Document:Internalised Danger	blog post	6 November 2020	Craig Murray	America urgently needs a radical dose of social and economic reform as championed by Bernie Sanders. It needs the Green New Deal, and the world needs a real commitment in Washington to environmentalism.
Document:Is the burning of fossil fuel a significant planetary activity?	article	21 August 2010	Denis Rancourt
Document:No Need to Panic About Global Warming	article	28 January 2012	Editorial staff
Document:People and Data Cherry-Picked For the IPCC Political Agenda	article	20 April 2014	Tim Ball	A cogent critique of the UN IPCC personnel and methodology designed to suborn and harness science to a clearly political agenda. Written by a Doyen of climate science and author of the book "The Deliberate Corruption of Climate Science".
Document:Rosebank: Omnicide for the People	Article	28 September 2023	Mike Small	Rosebank is the next step in the grotesque experience we are all living through: omnicide.
Document:Some Big Lies of Science	article	8 June 2010	Denis Rancourt
Document:The Corporate Climate Coup	article	1 May 2007	David F. Noble
Document:The Gargantuan Lie of Climate Science	article	21 March 2011	Denis Rancourt
Document:There is no future for Labour in bureaucratic centrism	Article	11 November 2020	Ian Lavery	Whilst many in the media and party establishments are keen to turn back the clock to the bureaucratic centrism, progressives energised on both sides of the Atlantic, whether by Corbyn or Sanders, will define our future politics.
File:A-Z ClimateRealityCheck.pdf	report	7 December 2011	ClimateDepot.com	This Climate Depot special report categorizes and indexes the full range of climate developments in a handy A-Z reference guide. The A-Z report includes key facts, peer-reviewed studies and the latest data and developments with links for further reading, on an exhaustive range of man-made global warming claims.
File:Climategate-emails.pdf	article	March 2010	John Costella
File:Global Climate Alarmism and Historical Precedents.pdf	paper	September 2013	Richard Lindzen	Authoritative opinion from one of the world's leading climate scientists and IPCC member working on the 1995 and 2001 Assessment reports
File:WFS klaus lecture 2012.pdf	speech	August 2012	Václav Klaus	"I feel obliged to warn against the arguments and ambitions of the believers in the global warming doctrine..."
New Climate Reality, New Media	Article	10 August 2021	Mike Small	Call out the worst of columnists and publications spouting writing that is clearly against the common good and against humanity’s future. A weekly prize for the worst culprits. Naming and shaming disinformation and sponsored propaganda.

 

Official examples

Name
2023 Hawaii wildfires
2024 Persian Gulf floods
C40 Cities Climate Leadership Group

Many thanks to our Patrons who cover ~2/3 of our hosting bill. Please join them if you can.