|Born||Thomas Dalyell Loch|
|Died||2017-01-26 (Age 84)|
West Lothian, Scotland
|Alma mater||Edinburgh Academy, Eton College, King's College (Cambridge)|
|Member of||Justice for Megrahi|
Labour MP who posed the "West Lothian Question"
Sir Thomas Dalyell Loch, 11th Baronet, known as Tam Dalyell, was a British Labour Party politician who was a Member of Parliament in the House of Commons from 1962 to 2005. He represented West Lothian from 1962 to 1983, then Linlithgow from 1983 to 2005.
On 14 November 1977, Tam Dalyell asked during a House of Commons debate over Scottish and Welsh devolution:
- "For how long will English constituencies and English Honourable members tolerate ... at least 119 Honourable Members from Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland exercising an important, and probably often decisive, effect on English politics while they themselves have no say in the same matters in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland?"
He illustrated his point by pointing out the absurdity of an MP for West Lothian being able to vote on matters affecting the English town of Blackburn, Lancashire, but not Blackburn, West Lothian, in his own constituency. The name "West Lothian Question" was coined by the Ulster Unionist MP Enoch Powell in his response to Dalyell's speech:
- "We have finally grasped what the Honourable Member for West Lothian is getting at. Let us call it the "West Lothian Question".
- 1 Background
- 2 Career
- 3 Activities
- 4 Criticism of Tony Blair
- 5 Post retirement
- 6 Family
- 7 Bibliography
- 8 Documents by Tam Dalyell
- 9 Related Documents
- 10 References
- 11 External links
Born in Edinburgh, but raised in his mother Nora Dalyell's family home, The Binns, near Linlithgow, West Lothian; his father (Percy) Gordon Loch, C.I.E., was an Empire civil servant (Political Agent) and a scion of the Loch family. His father took his wife's maiden name in 1938, and through his mother he inherited the baronetcy of the Binns in 1972, although he never uses the title.
Tam Dalyell was educated at the Edinburgh Academy and Eton and did his National Service with the Royal Scots Greys from 1950 to 1952 – as an ordinary trooper, after failing his officer training. He then went to King's College (Cambridge) to study History and Economics, where he was Chairman of the Cambridge University Conservative Association, and Vice-President of the Cambridge Union Society but failed to be elected to its presidency.
Dalyell then trained as a teacher at Moray House College in Edinburgh and taught at Bo'ness Academy and a ship school. He joined the Labour Party in 1956 after the Suez Crisis. He has been a columnist for the New Scientist magazine since 1967. Recently he has also been a strong supporter of Classical subjects (Greek and Roman studies) in higher education.
Tam Dalyell became a Member of Parliament in June 1962, when he defeated William Wolfe of the Scottish National Party in a hard fought by-election for West Lothian. From 1983 onwards, he represented Linlithgow (when the new town of Livingston split off to form its own constituency) and easily retained his position as their representative. He became Father of the House after the 2001 General Election, when Sir Edward Heath retired. He was a Member of the European Parliament from 1975 to 1979, and a member of the Labour National Executive from 1986 to 1987 for the Campaign group.
Dalyell's independent stance in Parliament ensured his isolation from significant committees and jobs. His early career was promising and he became Parliamentary Private Secretary (PPS) to Richard Crossman, but he annoyed a number of ministers and was heavily censured by the Committee on Standards and Privileges for a leak about the biological weapons research establishment Porton Down to the newspapers (though he claimed that he thought the minutes were in the public domain). When Labour failed to hold power in 1970 his chances of senior office were effectively over. He was opposed to Scottish devolution and first posed the famous "West Lothian question", although it was given its name by Enoch Powell. He continued to argue his own causes: in 1978 to 1979 he voted against his own government over 100 times, despite a three-line whip.
Dalyell is vocal in his disapproval of imperialism. Beginning with his opposition to action in Borneo in 1965, he has contested almost every British action – arguing against action in Aden, the depopulation of Diego Garcia, the Falklands War (especially the sinking of the General Belgrano), the Gulf War, and action in Kosovo and Iraq, saying, "I will resist a war with every sinew in my body". When invited by a television journalist to rank Tony Blair among the eight prime ministers he had observed as a parliamentarian, he cited policy over Kosovo and Iraq as reasons for placing Blair bottom of the list.
Exposure of the Al-Yamamah arms deal
In October 1994, MP Tam Dalyell submitted documents to parliament that he claimed proved Mark Thatcher was also involved and received a £12 million commission on the Al-Yamamah arms deal signed off by his mother while she was UK Prime Minister. The Public Accounts Committee (United Kingdom) decided not to investigate.
Tam Dalyell was also a strong presence in Parliament concerning Libya and led 17 adjournment debates on the Lockerbie bombing, in which he repeatedly demanded answers by the government to the reports of Hans Köchler, United Nations observer at the Lockerbie trial.
In 1995, Tam Dalyell asked the Lord Advocate, Lord Rodger of Earlsferry, to grant diplomatic immunity to Lester Coleman, a co-author of Trail of the Octopus, so that he could give evidence in the Lockerbie bombing trial in Scotland; the Federal Government of the United States had indictments against Coleman, accusing him of passport fraud and perjury. Allan Stewart, a former Scotland Office minister and Conservative Party MP for Eastwood, also said that Coleman should be granted immunity so he could testify in Scotland. The Lord Advocate rejected Dalyell's plea, saying that the Home Office and the English courts have the jurisdiction over the US government's extradition demand regarding Coleman, and that the Crown Office and the Scottish Office had no authority over the case. Dalyell later said "I had contact with Les Coleman 10 years ago. In my opinion, though he has a chequered history, I take him seriously."
US agent Abu Nidal
In October 2008, intelligence reports emerged suggesting that Lockerbie bombing suspect Abu Nidal was a US agent. Apparently drawn up for Saddam Hussein's security services, the reports said the Kuwaitis had asked Abu Nidal (aka Sabri al-Banna) to find out if al-Qaeda was present in Iraq. Tam Dalyell claimed these reports, which referred to Abu Nidal's "collusion with both the American and Kuwaiti intelligence apparatuses in co-ordination with Egyptian intelligence", added weight to the theory that Lockerbie was a "tit-for-tat" attack for the shooting down of Iran Air Flight 655 by the USS Vincennes in July 1988, and that the US administration was complicit. Dalyell said the claims that Abu Nidal was working for the Americans would explain some of the mysteries surrounding the Lockerbie disaster for example:
- The notice that went up at the American embassy in Moscow warning diplomats not to travel on Pan Am flights;
- Senior South African figures being "hauled off" the plane;
- Why prime minister Margaret Thatcher overruled her transport secretary, Cecil Parkinson, and stopped a public inquiry into the attack.
In a joint statement issued on 25 October 2008, Tam Dalyell and Professor Robert Black said:
- "If the American public had known of a link with Abu Nidal, and had known that the US government knew enough to pull VIPs off the plane and let home-going students take their place, there would have been fury at a time of transition between the presidencies of Ronald Reagan and George Bush Snr. The fact that the Iraqi government either executed Abu Nidal or forced him to commit suicide suggests they had discovered he was an American spy."
The Megrahi I know
On 31 October 2008, the website of The Times carried an opinion piece by Tam Dalyell headed "A civilised, caring man - not a mass murderer" and subtitled "The Megrahi I know":
- "My deep conviction, as a 'Professor of Lockerbie studies' over a 20-year period is that neither al-Megrahi nor Libya had any role in the destruction of Pan Am 103.
- "I believe they were made a scapegoat in 1990-91 by an American government that had decided to go to war with Iraq and did not want complications with Syria and Iran, which had harboured the real perpetrators of the terrible deed. Libya and its 'operatives', Al-Amin Khalifa Fhimah (al-Megrahi's co-accused) and al-Megrahi, only came into the frame at a very late date. In my informed opinion, al-Megrahi has been the victim of one of the most spectacular (and expensive) miscarriages of justice in history. (...)
- "Visiting him in prison, I was struck by his self-possession - a self-possession that had struck many people at his trial, possibly because it never occurred to him that he would be found guilty. It explains my passionate involvement over 20 years, as well as that of Robert Black, Professor Emeritus of Scots law at the University of Edinburgh. It was on our say-so that Libya ever surrendered its citizens to Scottish justice. Whatever happens to al-Megrahi, faced with advanced terminal cancer, the case will continue because on trial is the international reputation of Scottish justice and particularly of the Crown Office...
- "Almost the last thing that al-Megrahi said to me was: 'Yes, of course I want to go back to Tripoli. I have my wife and my five children are growing up, but I want to go back an innocent man.'
- "Some of us are determined to find the truth and justice that we believe will find him innocent."
On 6 November 2008, The Times printed the following "clarification":
In Tam Dalyell's article in last Saturday's Times "A civilised, caring man - not a mass murderer", Mr Dalyell claimed that the prosecution in the Lockerbie case had lied to Lord Coulsfield, the High Court judge, when it told the trial court at Camp Zeist that it had full confidence in the evidence of the Maltese shopkeeper, Tony Gauci. Mr Dalyell's claim was based on reported comments made by a previous Lord Advocate, Lord Fraser of Carmyllie, that Mr Gauci was an unreliable witness who was "not the full shilling". The present Lord Advocate has asked us to point out that Lord Fraser made it clear in 2005 that he did not have any reservations about any aspect of the prosecution, and had no aspersions to cast on Tony Gauci's evidence and, therefore, that there is no substance to the serious allegation in the article that the Crown had lied to the court about its confidence in the evidence of Tony Gauci.
Criticism of Tony Blair
Following his outspoken opposition to the 2003 invasion of Iraq and criticism of the government, Downing Street suggested that he might face withdrawal of the Labour whip. Dalyell stated in an interview with the American magazine Vanity Fair that Prime Minister Tony Blair was unduly influenced by a "cabal of Jewish advisers." He specifically named Lord Levy who was Blair's official representative in the Middle East and Labour politicians Peter Mandelson (whose father was Jewish) and Jack Straw (whose great-grandfather was Jewish). Mandelson said that "apart from the fact that I am not actually Jewish, I wear my father's parentage with pride." Dalyell denied accusations that the remarks were anti-Semitic. In March 2003, regarding the 2003 invasion of Iraq, Tam Dalyell accused the then Prime Minister Tony Blair of being a war criminal, stating: "Since Mr Blair is going ahead with his support for a US attack without unambiguous UN authorisation, he should be branded as a war criminal and sent to The Hague."
On 7 March 2003, Dalyell was elected Rector of the University of Edinburgh by the staff and students. He was succeeded in 2006 by Mark Ballard. It was announced on 13 January 2004 that he would stand down at the next election, and he left the House of Commons in April 2005 after 43 years as a member of the Commons. He had been Scotland's longest-serving MP since the resignation of Bruce Millan in 1988. He was succeeded as Father of the House by Alan Williams. On 16 May 2009, the Daily Telegraph reported that Dalyell had claimed £18,000 for three bookcases just months before his retirement from the House of Commons. Dalyell, however, claimed that this was a legitimate expense to which he was entitled; the House of Commons' Fees Office finally released £7,800.
Tam Dalyell married Kathleen Wheatley, a teacher, on 26 December 1963. They have one son, Gordon Wheatley Dalyell, and one daughter, both of whom are lawyers. He is a 6th cousin of Harry S. Truman through the daughter of the 1st Baronet Dalyell of the Binns. In his retirement, and for some years previously, he has contributed obituaries to The Independent. In 2011 he published his autobiography, The Importance of Being Awkward. The dedication is "To the men and women of West Lothian – Labour, SNP, Conservative, Liberal, Communist – who, whatever their political opinions, were kind to me in all sorts of ways over 43 years as their representative in the House of Commons."
- The Case of Ship-Schools, 1960
- Ship-School Dunera, 1963
- Devolution: The End of Britain?, 1977
- One Man's Falklands, 1982
- A Science Policy for Britain, 1983
- Thatcher's Torpedo, 1983
- Misrule, 1987
- Dick Crossman: A Portrait, 1989
- The Importance of Being Awkward: The Autobiography of Tam Dalyell, 2011
Documents by Tam Dalyell
|Title||Document type||Publication date||Subject(s)||Description|
|Document:Allan Francovich Obituary||obituary||28 April 1997||Allan Francovich||"He was, above all, a seeker after truth, wheresoever that truth might lead." - An appreciation from a friend.|
|Document:Megrahi Obituary||obituary||21 May 2012||Abdelbaset al-Megrahi||The day after Abdelbaset al-Megrahi died, Tam Dalyell opines that he was not the Lockerbie bomber.|
|Document:The Crime of Lockerbie||Article||16 August 2009||Pan Am Flight 103|
The Downing Street Years
|Tam Dalyell said: "Yes, I have read 'The Downing Street Years' very carefully. Why in 800 pages did you not mention Lockerbie once?" Mrs Thatcher replied: "Because I didn’t know what happened and I don’t write about things that I don’t know about."|
|Document:South Africa Minister Denies Knowing Of Lockerbie Bomb||Abstract||12 November 1994||David Tucker||Having confirmed that South African foreign minister Pik Botha and his 22-strong party had been booked on Pan Am Flight 103 but switched flights after arriving early in London from Johannesburg, spokesman Roland Darroll said: "The minister is flattered by the allegation of near-omniscience."|
|Document:Unanswered questions over Lockerbie||Article||January 1995||Phil Johnson||According to Tam Dalyell MP: "The American and British governments do not want the film shown. The American families do not want the film shown because they want their compensation money ($2.7 billion). More importantly, their lawyers want their money ($810 million)."|
- "The West Lothian Question"
- "What is the West Lothian question and why does it matter?"
- Loch, Percy Gordon (1934) The Family Loch, Privately Printed P202
- "Tam Dalyell: This is my 17th and probably last Adjournment debate on Lockerbie"
- "Lockerbie debate, Hansard, 1 May 2002"
- "Immunity ruled out in Lockerbie row. Plea to Lord Advocate fails over former US intelligence agent" The Herald. 4 August 1995. Retrieved on 11 October 2010.
- "Was Lockerbie suspect working for US?"
- "Tam Dalyell: The Megrahi I know"
- "Fury as Dalyell attacks Blair's 'Jewish cabal'"
- Nicholas Watt "Dalyell may face race hatred inquiry", The Guardian, 5 May 2003
- "Dalyell's 'Jewish cabal' remarks denied", BBC News, 4 May 2003
- Michael White "Dalyell steps up attack on Levy", The Guardian, 6 May 2003
- Tam Dalyell "Blair, the war criminal", The Guardian, 27 March 2003
- BBC News "Labour MP faces mortgage claims" retrieved 16 May 2009
- "MP 'relaxed' about bookcase claim"
- Tam Dalyell to step down at 2005 election
- BBC NEWS | Politics | Tam Dalyell
- Tam Dalyell – the longest serving MP
- Tam Dalyell, former MP Linlithgow
- Westminster Diary: Tam Dalyell Column from New Scientist magazine
- Blair the war criminal by Tam Dalyell article about Tony Blair in The Guardian newspaper 27 March 2003
- Tam Dalyell Profile – 'Heckling for Britain' – from The Guardian newspaper 13 April 2002