Abu Agila Mas'ud
| Abu Agila Masud|
Abu Ajila Masoud pictured in 2015 at his trial in Tripoli sitting behind Abdullah al-Senussi
Abu Agila Mas'ud (aka Mohammed Abouagela Masud, the Technician) was described in a Sunday Express article of 3 February 2013 as the mystery "third man" in the 1988 Lockerbie bombing conspiracy, for which Abdelbaset al-Megrahi was convicted in 2001, and Lamin Khalifah Fhimah was acquitted.
Seven years were to elapse before, on 14 December 2020 in Washington, FBI Special Agent Rachel Otto signed an Affidavit in support of a criminal complaint against Masud. On 21 December 2020, Lockerbie's 32nd anniversary, outgoing US Attorney General William Barr formally indicted Abu Agila Mas'ud Kheir Al-Marimi for participating in the “Lockerbie airplane bombing,” among other plots against the United States and the West including, but not limited to, the 5 April 1986 La Belle discotheque bombing in West Berlin, Germany.
On 12 December 2022, a day after Masud was brought to America, US Magistrate Judge Robin Meriweather ordered Masud to remain in custody at least until a detention hearing on 27 December 2022. Recalling that Nelson Mandela had said that "no one country should be complainant, prosecutor and judge" in the case of the Lockerbie bombing, Dr Jim Swire said the suspect Abu Agila Masud should be tried in a court chosen by the United Nations.
On 13 February 2023, Human Rights Watch said the United States and Libyan authorities should clarify the legal basis for Masud's abusive arrest and subsequent extradition:
Concern over Masud's arrest
On 11 December 2022, the BBC reported that Abu Agila Masud was in US custody. Lawyer Aamer Anwar representing the family of Abdelbaset al-Megrahi said:
- “The United States claims that Masud’s confession to being involved in the conspiracy with Al-Megrahi to blow up Pan Am Flight 103, was ‘extracted’ by a ‘Libyan law enforcement agent’ in 2012, whilst in custody in a Libyan prison. (That prison, until taken over after a day-long heavy fighting in 2017, was under the control of the terrorist group Libyan Islamic Fighting Group.)
- "What the US should have said was that Masud was actually in the custody of a war lord, widely condemned for human rights abuses and the circumstances in which such a confession was extracted would be strongly opposed in any US/Scottish court.
- "The US criminal complaint against Masud states that he bought the clothes to put into the Samsonite suitcase that is claimed went on to blow up Pan Am Flight 103. The problem for the US Department of Justice is that the case against Megrahi is still based on the eyewitness testimony of Tony Gauci, stating that Megrahi bought the clothes."
Foreign minister Hafed Gaddur has announced that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation in the government appointed by Libya's House of Representatives will hire an international law firm to defend Masud.
In November 2022, it was reported that Brigadier General Masoud Abu Ajila al-Marimi, a former Libyan External Security Organisation (ESO) officer, was kidnapped by unknown persons, on the basis of allegations regarding his “role in the Lockerbie case 33 years after its occurrence,” which sparked controversy and condemnation in Libya. According to a report by London-based newspaper Asharq Al-Awsat, the interim Government of National Unity, headed by Abdul Hamid al-Dabaiba, faces widespread accusations of attempting to extradite Abu Ajila as a “scapegoat” for the United States, in return for “his government’s continuation in the power it has held for nearly two years.” Professor Robert Black KC commented:
If Masud has been handed over to the Americans for trial, that could be a good thing. Maybe an American jury court wouldn't be as gullible as the Scottish judges at Zeist. And a lot of evidence favourable to the defence has emerged since 2001.
Meanwhile, on 23 November 2022, the Libyan House of Representatives stated that it would request the trial of anyone proven to be involved in the attempt to reopen the Lockerbie case file, on charges of “high treason,” announcing its categorical refusal to extradite citizen Abu Ajila Masoud to the United States.
US Department of Injustice
On 18 December 2022, in a post to Facebook, journalist Ian Ferguson wrote:
- "The kidnapping and abduction of an alleged former Libyan intelligence operative accused of preparing the bomb that brought down Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland, in 1988 and his rendition into US custody raises massive concerns about Washington’s arrogant behaviour in continuing to flout international law to hunt alleged terrorist fugitives.
- "What we are likely to see unfold in a US courtroom is a further attempt to ensure that Libya continues to be held responsible for the attack on Pan Am 103.
- "Will we see a plethora of allegations, unsupported by facts? Probably yes.
- "Will they pull another 'stellar' witness like Abdul Majid Giaka, out of their bag of tricks? Who knows.
- "With the US Department of Justice behind this we can be assured that just as in the Lockerbie trial in the Netherlands, no stone will be left unturned in getting to a predetermined outcome of Guilty.
- "How can anyone take the US version of events seriously, when they start the process by using extraordinary rendition AKA kidnapping. No doubt they had assistance from senior Libyan government officials, hoping to curry favour with the US.
- "All in all, a travesty of justice from the outset but let’s not kid ourselves. The US and the Scottish Crown has never sought the truth in the Lockerbie affair. It was a reversed engineering affair…..the Libyans did it and lets go backwards and prove it. Contempt prior to investigation! With all of the resources at their disposal the two countries, Scotland and the US, managed to get a conviction on one of the accused, Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed Al Megrahi and his co-accused Lamin Khalifah Fhimah was acquitted.
- "I sat through almost every day of the Lockerbie trial and there was never any solid evidence against Megrahi. All circumstantial with the additional help of millions of $US being paid to the late Tony Gauci for his evidence that Megrahi bought clothes (allegedly found in the wreckage of the aircraft) from him in his shop. Oddly enough in several conversations I had with Gauci in the years leading up to the trial, he changed his story multiple times. Clearly it was such a memorable occasion when a purchaser bought clothes in a clothes shop! And he even remembered how much change he gave the customer.
- "Couple Gauci’s 'evidence' with the rantings of Giaka…job done!
- "Anyone who believes that this current US prosecution is an attempt get to the truth, is in my opinion delusional.
- "The Scottish Court in the Netherlands, wrongfully, in my opinion, convicted Megrahi.
- "My guess is the US Court will find Mohammed Abouagela Masud, guilty.
- "It matters not, to the US Department of Injustice if there is no solid evidence against Masud…..it did not matter in the case against Megrahi, so why change a winning formula.
- "Time to bring on the cheerleaders from the FBI to celebrate yet another victory even before the case starts.
- "I have no doubts that Megrahi’s conviction will eventually be overturned.
Case against Masud 'would crumble'
According to the affidavit in support of the indictment, Masud was instructed by a Libyan intelligence official in Tripoli to fly to Malta with a prepared suitcase. Masud allegedly did so, where he was met by Megrahi and Fhimah at the airport and spent approximately three or four days there in a hotel. Megrahi and Fhimah allegedly instructed Masud to set the timer on the device in the medium-sized Samsonite suitcase on the morning of 21 December 1988, so that the explosion would occur exactly eleven hours later. Masud then handed the bomb suitcase to Fhimah who placed it on the airport conveyor belt. After which, Masud left Malta and returned to Libya.
On 15 January 2021, following the Judgment of the High Court of Justiciary rejecting Megrahi's posthumous appeal against conviction, lawyer Aamer Anwar said:
“Significant material has been received by the legal team over the last several months. Especially since the announcement by Donald Trump’s former Attorney General William Barr on 21 December 2020, where he stated that the USA wished to extradite a former Libyan Intelligence Officer, Abu Agila Mohammad Masud for the Lockerbie bombing, 32 years later.
“Masud’s confession to being involved in the conspiracy with al-Megrahi to blow up Pan Am Flight 103, was supposedly ‘extracted’ by a ‘Libyan law enforcement agent’ in 2012, whilst in custody in a Libyan Prison. No new information appeared to be presented by Attorney General Barr.
“What was significant in the US criminal complaint against Masud was his claim that he bought the clothes to put into the Samsonite suitcase that is claimed went on to blow up Pan Am Flight 103.
“Of course, the problem for the US Department of Justice is that the case against Megrahi is still based on the eyewitness testimony of Tony Gauci stating that Megrahi bought the clothes. How can both men be held responsible?
“The al-Megrahi family believe that if the conviction against their father were to be overturned then the US case against Masud would be non-existent. Undoubtedly there will now be huge pressure on Libya and the GNA, the Government of National Accord based in Tripoli to extradite Abu Agila Masud to the US, but of course the American authorities will be also aware that if the Megrahi’s were to be successful at the UK Supreme Court, then ‘so called’ case against Abu Masud would crumble.”
Secret court hearings
A series of secret court hearings in Malta, requested by Scottish prosecutors and held in September 2012 behind closed doors, were focused on gathering evidence about other co-conspirators. The most likely candidate was reported to be Mas'ud, who worked with Megrahi and Fhimah in Malta - where prosecutors said the bomb that brought down Pan Am Flight 103 was planted at Luqa Airport. One Lockerbie expert said:
- "It's possible they are looking at Mas'ud, who allegedly arrived in Malta with Megrahi and was said to have been with him when he flew out of the country on the day of the bombing. He was also accused of plotting with Megrahi to mount an operation in Africa. I don't think the police ever found him."
Mas'ud and several of the other suspects were first linked to the Lockerbie case by controversial CIA informant Majid Giaka. The junior Libyan intelligence officer, who was on secondment at Libyan Arab Airlines (LAA), claimed he saw Mas'ud arriving at the airport in Malta with Megrahi in December 1988. He alleged they met Fhimah and collected a suitcase from baggage reclaim resembling the Samonsite case which contained the bomb.
Shoring up the Malta connection
Justice for Megrahi campaign member Professor Robert Black, a lawyer who was the architect of the original Lockerbie trial in the Netherlands, said:
- "It looks like the Crown Office is trying to shore up the Malta connection, which is pretty weak."
A Crown Office spokeswoman said:
- "The investigation into the involvement of others with Megrahi in the Lockerbie bombing remains open and Dumfries and Galloway Constabulary continues to work with Crown Office and US authorities to pursue available lines of inquiry."
Dornstein's unfulfilled quest
Filmmaker Ken Dornstein set out in 2011 on a quest to identify a number of Libyan suspects who could have been responsible for the death of his elder brother David in the 1988 Lockerbie bombing. The first step was getting former SIO Stuart Henderson to provide him with a list of eight to ten names of individuals from the files of the original investigation who seemed to play a role in the bombing but who had never been indicted.
- "My idea was a pretty simple idea - to go with a list of names, start knocking on doors and find out who these persons were and would any of them tell me the truth," Dornstein said.
Dornstein quickly found out that many of those named in the investigation were dead. Some had been killed before the revolution that led to the overthrow of Muammar Gaddafi. Some were killed during the revolution while others appeared to have been killed on orders from Gaddafi himself.
- "By my count there were three people left alive who I believe played a role in it and who I was focused on trying to identify and find," Dornstein said.
Of those the most intriguing was a mysterious figure who Dornstein said had been travelling with Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, the only person convicted in the attack, including on the day of the bombing.
- "I thought if I could figure out who that person was, potentially that would make sense of the whole case." Dornstein said.
Dornstein was eventually able to connect a passport number (835004) of the suspected explosives expert to a matching passport number linked by East German secret police to the bombing of a disco in Berlin a few years before Lockerbie. For a long time Dornstein, and investigators, weren't sure that the individual - a Libyan named Abu Agila Mas'ud - was even real.
- "This is a guy who had essentially been a ghost. There was no photo of him. The FBI and Scottish police - nobody had a photo of him. There were suspicions that he didn't even exist," Dornstein said. "The Libyans always denied his existence."
Dornstein was able to track down Mas'ud to a jail in Libya where he says he was serving a 10-plus year sentence on bomb-making charges for booby-trapping the cars of those opposed to Gaddafi.
- "I wish I had come face to face to him," said Dornstein, who only dealt with Mas'ud indirectly. "I would have liked to have been there for the moment when someone tapped him on the shoulder and said 'Hey, here's this incident that happened all these years ago and there's someone in America - someone's brother - who said you connected the wires that maybe blew up that plane and killed some 270 people.' I would have loved to have been there to see his reaction and hear his answer."
Dornstein ultimately turned his search for the Pan Am Flight 103 bombers into a three-part PBS Frontline documentary film "My Brother's Bomber".
In the film, shown on BBC Four on 2 November 2015, Dornstein revealed that Libyan double agent Musbah Eter had supplied him with a photograph of the elusive Mas'ud. Dornstein matched the photo of Mas'ud to the man he'd spotted in the back seat of the car sent to Tripoli airport to meet Abdelbaset al-Megrahi on 20 August 2009, upon Megrahi's compassionate release from prison in Scotland. Also pictured in the car on that occasion was Abdullah al-Senussi. Without any corroborating evidence, Eter told Dornstein that Mas'ud had actually admitted to the 1986 La Belle discotheque bombing in Berlin, to the 1988 Lockerbie bombing and to the sabotage in 1989 of UTA Flight 772. Interviewed in the film by Dornstein, Edwin Bollier said although he recognised the dark-skinned Mas'ud from the photograph he didn't know his name.
Close to 1991 indictment
On 18 October 2015, the Scotland on Sunday reported that Mas'ud had been close to being indicted in 1991:
One of the new suspects in the Lockerbie bombing was “very close” to being indicted at the original trial along with Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, according to the former FBI agent who headed up the US investigation. Richard Marquise said prosecutors decided against the move to pursue Abu Agila Mas’ud because they didn’t believe the case was strong enough. Scottish prosecutors last week announced that are seeking permission to interview two new suspects, later confirmed as Mas’ud and Libya’s ex-intelligence chief Abdullah al-Senussi. Both are currently incarcerated in the strife-torn North African state with Senussi facing the death sentence and Mas’ud jailed for ten years.
Marquise is a former FBI agent and was head of the US government’s investigation of the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 which killed 270 people in 1988. He said both men were on the radar in the original investigation.
- “Senussi was Gaddafi’s intelligence chief as I recall,” he said. “We had him as a possible suspect only because of his rank in the government and what he did there. We didn’t have any evidence against him, but he was someone we were well aware of and we had heard stories that he was involved deeply in terrorist plots, but nothing specific in regard to Lockerbie. Mas’ud on the other hand, he was very close to being indicted back when Megrahi was. We were aware of his travels with Megrahi in and out of Malta, a number of times. The last time that we were aware of was the morning that the bomb bag left. He and Megrahi were on the same plane. So we were aware of him. He was, we believed he was, a technician of some kind – a bomb builder. However, there was no real evidence against him other than that he was a bomb technician and he was on a flight with Megrahi. So prosecutors decided back in 1991 not to indict him. I think the prosecutors erred on the side of caution to say there’s no real concrete evidence. Nobody told us, well he came here and armed the bomb or put the timer together. There’s no real proof of that.”
However, Middle East expert Jason Pack said the idea of Lockerbie investigators going to Libya to interrogate suspects in its current state of turmoil was an absurdity. Even if investigators did manage to gain access to the prisoners, Lockerbie campaigner Morag Kerr doubted that anything would be achieved:
- "Any case against Abdullah al-Senussi and Mas’ud would be based on the same essential evidence that was used to convict Megrahi in the first place. But that evidence has been systematically dismantled and discredited over a number of years. If that were to be tested in court then against new suspects, I’m afraid I would be very doubtful it would even get to court."
On 16 December 2020, The Guardian reported that William Barr, the outgoing US Attorney General, was expected to confirm publicly within days that the US has indicted a former Libyan intelligence officer, Mohammed Abouagela Masud, accusing him of completing the device which blew up Pan Am Flight 103. The expected indictment comes as five of Scotland’s most senior judges are considering a posthumous appeal brought by the family of Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, the only man convicted of the attack.
Aamer Anwar, speaking for the Megrahi family, said the decision by the US Department of Justice was designed to sway the Scottish court:
- “It smacks of extreme desperation that on the eve of a decision on the appeal and the 32nd anniversary of the bombing that they should come up with an indictment of Masud. What have they been doing for the last 32 years?
- “It’s a weak and tenuous link, trying to connect Megrahi to him.”
Professor Robert Black QC said he doubted the timing of William Barr’s decision would affect the Scottish judges weighing up Megrahi’s appeal case.
- “I honestly don’t think that would have an influence on the Scottish judiciary. There have been numerous occasions where contradictory claims had surfaced before with Lockerbie hearings outside the court setting which had not swayed the court."
|Document:Call for US to give update on fourth Lockerbie suspect||Article||18 December 2022||Kathleen Nutt||Former Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill: "Britain and America know everything. I want the UK and US to be more open. Libya have offered up Abu Agila Masud. But Masud is smaller beer. The Lord Advocate should find out what progress is being made on bringing Abdullah Senussi to court."|
- ↑ "Affidavit in Support of a Criminal Complaint"
- ↑ "Decades After Lockerbie Bombing, US Charges Libyan as 3rd Conspirator"
- ↑ "Former Senior Libyan Intelligence Officer and Bomb-Maker for the Muamar Qaddafi Regime Charged for The December 21, 1988 Bombing of Pan Am Flight 103"
- ↑ "Lockerbie bombing suspect will not face death penalty"
- ↑ "Call for UN to choose Lockerbie bomb trial court"
- ↑ "Human rights concerns in Lockerbie suspect’s rendition"
- ↑ "Lockerbie bombing suspect in US custody"
- ↑ "Libyan commentator's assessment of the Masud affair"
- ↑ "Lawyer of only man convicted of Lockerbie bombing 'concerned' by arrest of suspect in US"
- ↑ "Gaddur: We will hire an international law firm to defend Abu Agila Masud"
- ↑ "Libyan official warns against raising the Lockerbie issue"
- ↑ "Abu Ageila Masud and Lockerbie"
- ↑ "Lockerbie cover up still haunts Libyans to this day"
- ↑ "Abduction of Lockerbie suspect 'was deal between US and Tripoli Government'"
- ↑ "Abducted Libyan 'may have already left for America under guard'"
- ↑ "Libya to prosecute those involved in reopening of Lockerbie file"
- ↑ "The kidnapping and abduction of Masud"
- ↑ "LOCKERBIE – Analysis of the New Indictment by Intel Today"
- ↑ "Al-Megrahi family 'devastated' as Lockerbie appeal court judges uphold conviction"
- ↑ "Two Libyans identified as Lockerbie bombing suspects"
- ↑ "Lockerbie: Seven new Libyans named"
- ↑ "A filmmaker's quest to ID men behind Lockerbie bombing"
- ↑ "Lockerbie: My Brother's Bomber"
- ↑ "Lockerbie bomb suspect ‘close to being indicted’"
- ↑ "Transcript of BBC Radio Scotland programme Good Morning Scotland," 17 October 2015, (17’20’’ to 29’37’’)
- ↑ "US set to announce new charges over Lockerbie plane bombing"