Difference between revisions of "Wikispooks:Standardisation"

From Wikispooks
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(names of books, films etc.)
(Clarify the standard about bolding the full name (with applicable titles))
 
(38 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{HelpSection|image=Standardisation.png}}
 
{{HelpSection|image=Standardisation.png}}
While trying to give users as much freedom as possible, it is nevertheless helpful to follow some standards while composing Wikispooks. The general approach is designed to make pages easy to find and interlink. Although, as a project page, this is only editable by administrators, all users are encouraged to contribute their ideas and comments to the [[{{TALKPAGENAME}}|talk page]].
+
'''Wikispooks has various standards''', which are important not only for clarity but particularly to help the software to automatically find and interlink material between different pages. Although this page is only editable by administrators,<ref>Since it is a "Wikispooks:" page</ref> all editors are encouraged to contribute their ideas and comments to the [[{{TALKPAGENAME}}|talk page]].
 +
==Templates for Pages==
 +
{{FA|Wikispooks:Semantic_Objects}}
 +
'''All pages in the {{NS|main}} ''must'' have exactly one object template'''. This determines broadly what the page is about and is needed by {{SMW}}. See [[Wikispooks:Semantic_Objects|here]] for a list of available objects. This policy was fixed in June 2014.
  
 
==Page Names==
 
==Page Names==
Naming of pages is obviously important so that links work as expected, but the importance goes deeper still with the use of [[WikiSpooks:Semantic Mediawiki|Semantic Mediawiki]] since these names become semantic 'anchors' used to connect data items.
+
Page names are a key part of helping people use the site. Names are obviously important so that [[help:Links|hyperlinks]] work as expected, but the use of [[Wikispooks:Semantic Mediawiki|Semantic Mediawiki]] add another level - these names become semantic 'anchors' used to connect data items. In addition, some [[Wikispooks:Templates]] parse page titles, e.g. to extract surnames from them. Ideals page names are short, descriptive ''and'' unambiguous.
  
 
===Using Wikipedia===
 
===Using Wikipedia===
Line 9: Line 12:
  
 
===Subpages===
 
===Subpages===
Subpages are a mediawiki feature that allows easy display of a hierarchy like structure, i.e. {{t|A/B}}. Since January 2014 Wikispooks has been using this, and policy is still evolving as regards subpages, but it is currently recommended to use of subpages whenever a hierarchical (dependent) relationship exists. For example, since the [[JFK Assassination]] is an aspect of the man himself, subpages should be used to reflect this fact, so the page is [[John F Kennedy/Assassination]]. Similarly, the Warren Commission, which covered up the crime, was a derivative event, so the page is a sub-sub-page: [[John F Kennedy/Assassination/Cover-up]].  
+
The character "{{t|/}}" has a special meaning in the context of pagenames, since Wikispooks uses mediawiki ''sub''pages to indicate a hierarchical (dependent) relationship. A page title of the form {{t|A/B}} can be read as "the {{t|B}} of {{t|A}}". For example, {{t|[[John F. Kennedy/Assassination]]}} is the {{t|[[assassination]]}} ''of'' {{t|[[John F. Kennedy]]}}. A redirect at [[JFK Assassination]] points to the longer form, which is semantically useful to the software. Similarly, the [[Warren Commission]], which covered up the crime, redirects to a sub-sub-page: [[John F. Kennedy/Assassination/Cover-up]].
  
Such standardised pagenames fulfill the role of binomial names in biology; existing in parallel with alternative common names, they provide an easily interpreted structure intended to help both software and humans in navigation around the pages, and could be used in conjunction with particular [[WikiSpooks:Semantic properties|Semantic properties]]. Common subpage names may include: assassination, cover-up, perpetrators, misc ...
+
Such standardised pagenames fulfill the role of binomial names in biology; existing in parallel with alternative common names, they provide an easily interpreted structure intended to help both software and humans in navigation around the pages, and could be used in conjunction with particular [[Wikispooks:Semantic properties|Semantic properties]]. Common subpage names include:  
 +
* [[assassination]], [[death]] or [[murder]]
 +
* [[exposure]] and/or [[cover-up]]
 +
* [[premature death]]
 +
* [[timeline]] ...
 +
 
 +
For [[event]]s which feature a country name in the title (e.g. the [[1953 Iranian coup d'état]]), best practice is to use a subpage, i.e. [[Iran/1953 coup d'état]], since this is short, clear and more helpful to viewers of the parent page - [[Iran]].
  
 
===People's Names===
 
===People's Names===
For consistency, and to redress [http://sourcewatch.org/index.php/Credentialism credentialism], pages of individuals should generally be devoid of a title. Where people are commonly referred to by their title, a redirect page is fine. e.g. [[Colonel Gaddafi]] is a redirect to the main page, [[Muammar Gaddafi]]. This can be varied where the title neatly resolves an ambiguity or where it has become integral to the name, e.g. "[[Dr Rola]]".
+
The first mention of a page topic should be in bold, at of very near to the start of the lede paragraph. To help disambiguate individuals, and to clarify their establishment credentials, ''this'' mention should include all middle names, initials, and titles awarded (whether from birth or as a result of actions carried out). For simplicity, consistency and to redress [[credentialism]], names of individuals should otherwise be devoid of titles.
+
 
 +
Where people are commonly referred to by their title, a redirect page is fine. e.g. [[Colonel Gaddafi]] is a redirect to the main page, [[Muammar Gaddafi]]. This can be varied where a title has become integral to the name, e.g. "[[Dr Rola]]". This site supports Unicode, so for non-English names you should have no trouble using the appropriate accented characters (ä, Ç, ë...).
 +
 
 +
====Disambiguation====
 +
Middle names and initials are generally deprecated, but provide one simple way to avoid ambiguity where people share the same first and last names, and are preferred to honorary titles for this purpose. Another option is to give a modifier in brackets after the name. Where only one other person shares the name, the lede should begin with a simple link in italics to the other page.<ref>e.g. [[Gareth Williams (politician)‎]]</ref>
 +
 
 +
====Pseudonyms====
 +
Pseudonyms should be placed within single quotes. (e.g. [['Stakeknife']])
 +
 
 +
====Initials====
 +
Generally, middle initials should be avoided in titles, unless this is helpful either for clarity or to avoid ambiguity. When using initials, always use a dot after them, to distinguish them from one letter names (such as [[U Thant]]).
 +
 
 
===Names of books, films etc.===
 
===Names of books, films etc.===
As of May 2014, Wikispooks has no clear policy on this. Putting them in ''italics'' might be a good simple standard, though more research needs to be carried out in this area before a policy is decided upon.
+
Since 2017, Wikispooks has recommended all names of [[publications]] should be in ''italics''. This allows for easy disambiguation of otherwise identically named concepts. For example, [[Alan Francovich]] produced a [[film]] entitled ''[[Operation Gladio (film)|Operation Gladio]]'' about the [[NATO]] [[Operation Gladio]]. Standards for the target page name are not set, but as usual it should be simple and clear (in this case, the italic text is a link to [[Operation Gladio (film)]]).
  
 
===Singular/Plural===
 
===Singular/Plural===
For consistency and clarity, page titles which are nouns should generally be given in the singular. So, the article about [[False Flag Attack]]s is actually entitled "''False Flag Attack''" - note that [[Help:Links|Mediawiki's link syntax]] means that this plurals can easily still be linked in like this: <nowiki>[[False Flag Attack]]s</nowiki>
+
For consistency and clarity, page titles which are nouns should generally be given in the singular. So, the article about [[False Flag Attack]]s is actually entitled "''False Flag Attack''" - note that [[Help:Links|Mediawiki's link syntax]] means that this plurals can be easily linked like this: {{t|<nowiki>[[False Flag Attack]]s</nowiki>}}
  
 
===Letter Case===
 
===Letter Case===
Mediawiki automatically capitalizes the first letter of each pagename, but for multiple word titles, there is ambiguity about whether the other words should be capitalized or not. e.g. [[False Flag Attack]] or [[False flag attack]]? The standard is to use lower case where possible. This was only adopted in February 2014, so many old page names do not follow it.
+
Mediawiki automatically capitalizes the first letter of each pagename, but for multiple word titles, there is ambiguity about whether the other words should be capitalized or not. e.g. [[False Flag Attack]] or [[False flag attack]]? The standard is to use lower case where possible. Subpages should have an initial capital. This policy was only adopted in February 2014, so some older page names do not yet follow it.
 +
 
 +
===Special Characters===
 +
Although this site has full support for unicode, not all other sites do, and since non-ascii characters can lead to unexpected results in some software,<ref>https://tedclancy.wordpress.com/2015/06/03/which-unicode-character-should-represent-the-english-apostrophe-and-why-the-unicode-committee-is-very-wrong/</ref> it is good practice to use standard ascii unless alternatives yield a tangible benefit - so use of foreign accents is recommended for names because of increased accuracy, but a simple apostrophe or quote mark is preferred to the unicode variants.
  
 
===Events with Dates===
 
===Events with Dates===
Many pagenames have dates for greater clarity or to avoid ambiguity (e.g. [[Iraq war 2003]]) '''Should these dates be after or before the rest of the page title?''' Wikispooks still lacks a clear standard on this.
+
Many pagenames have dates for greater clarity or to avoid ambiguity (e.g. the [[2003 Iraq war]]). Where a year is part of the title, it is recommended to put this first for consistency's sake, and also to help with sorting.
  
 
==Other Names==
 
==Other Names==
Although none are as widely used or as important as page names, there are a host of other items for which standards would simplify and improve WikiSpooks.
+
Although none are as widely used or as important as page names, there are a host of other items for which standards would simplify and improve Wikispooks.
  
 
===Categories===
 
===Categories===
Use of {{SMW}} is generally preferred over categories, since it offers a more modern and flexible system of organising content. However, on occasions, a simple category is all that is needed. In this case - although some legacy categories are in the singular - '''new categories should be ''plural'' nouns'''.
+
''{{SMW}} is preferred over categories for organising content'' as it is more modern and flexible. There is a legacy [[MediaWiki:Category_Tree|category tree]], but do not add categories to it or use categories. Categories ''are'' used however, for organising the [[#templates|templates]] which make up this site and the [[Project:Community_portal|community portal]].
  
 
===Properties===
 
===Properties===
{{FA|WikiSpooks:Semantic Properties}}
+
{{FA|Wikispooks:Semantic Properties}}
 
{{SMW}} uses relationships referred to as "Properties", most of which (but not all) have the form "Has ''something''".
 
{{SMW}} uses relationships referred to as "Properties", most of which (but not all) have the form "Has ''something''".
  
 
===Templates===
 
===Templates===
{{FA|WikiSpooks:Templates}}
+
As with properties, these are mostly used 'behind the scenes', so [[Wikispooks:templates|templates]] don't impinge on the user experience, but standardisation is important to facilitate collaboration between those who create them.
As with properties, these are mostly used 'behind the scenes', so they don't impinge much on the user experience, but standardisation of template names, structures and parameter names is important to allow more efficient coding and collaboration between those who do use templates.
+
 
 +
====Parameters====
 +
A standard for custom Wikispooks templates was fixed in June 2014, although it is not yet followed by all Wikispooks templates and is still subject to review. Parameter names should be :
 +
* all in lower case letters (although exceptions are possible, for clarity, e.g. "ON_" to differentiate [[official narrative]]s)
 +
* connected by underscores (_) and not spaces where multiple words exist
 +
''This standard does not apply to templates are imported other websites.''
 +
 
 +
 
 +
==Image size==
 +
There are no strict standards for image sizes, it is always a judgement call. Both aesthetic and — especially for small screen sizes — practical considerations apply. The commonest size is probably {{t|300px}}. Where a page already has several images, copying one of their widths is often a good choice. Especially wide and/or important images may merit a greater width, especially if they are intended to stand alone rather than alongside text.
 +
 
 +
==Redirects==
 +
If in doubt, more redirects is better than less. However, do check the correct spelling before you make a redirect. Creating lots of redirects for incorrect spellings is not generally useful. While it is good that users can follow the link, this obscures the fact that a red link is an easy way to spot the spelling mistake. It is important to avoid 'circular' redirects - ones which link back to the page.
 +
 
 +
==Whitespace==
 +
Mediawiki markup allows some flexibility as regards use of spaces. This section, for example, is headed {{t|<nowiki>== Whitespace ==</nowiki>}} but could equally be {{t|<nowiki>==Whitespace==</nowiki>}} or even {{t|<nowiki>== Whitespace==</nowiki>}}. Since it is not displayed to the reader, it is generally not of importance, but is relevant to use of [[Special:ReplaceText]]. For templates parameters, the preferred standard is ''to start each parameter in column 1 and not to include extraneous spaces'', so {{t|{{!}}<nowiki>description=...</nowiki>}} is preferred to {{t|{{!}}<nowiki>description =...</nowiki>}}<ref>See the source of most pages for an example.</ref>
  
{{WikiSpooks Footer/Policy}}
+
==Project links==
[[category:WikiSpooks Policy]]
+
The Mediawiki software automatically aliases the {{NS|Project}} to the {{NS|Wikispooks}}. This should be used in preference as it is more portable - or use the custom [[Template:WSLink]].
 +
{{Wikispooks Footer/Policy}}
 +
[[category:Wikispooks Policy]]

Latest revision as of 11:41, 21 February 2023

Standardisation.png

Wikispooks has various standards, which are important not only for clarity but particularly to help the software to automatically find and interlink material between different pages. Although this page is only editable by administrators,[1] all editors are encouraged to contribute their ideas and comments to the talk page.

Templates for Pages

Full article: Wikispooks:Semantic_Objects

All pages in the main: namespace must have exactly one object template. This determines broadly what the page is about and is needed by SMW. See here for a list of available objects. This policy was fixed in June 2014.

Page Names

Page names are a key part of helping people use the site. Names are obviously important so that hyperlinks work as expected, but the use of Semantic Mediawiki add another level - these names become semantic 'anchors' used to connect data items. In addition, some Wikispooks:Templates parse page titles, e.g. to extract surnames from them. Ideals page names are short, descriptive and unambiguous.

Using Wikipedia

Wikipedia is often a useful reference point as regards names, and all other factors being equal, provides a simple choice which will generally be understood. It should be noted that all other factors are not necessarily equal since pagenames are regularly massaged by interested parties, so while an equivalent Wikipedia page name is a good default, careful consideration is still warranted.

Subpages

The character "/" has a special meaning in the context of pagenames, since Wikispooks uses mediawiki subpages to indicate a hierarchical (dependent) relationship. A page title of the form A/B can be read as "the B of A". For example, John F. Kennedy/Assassination is the assassination of John F. Kennedy. A redirect at JFK Assassination points to the longer form, which is semantically useful to the software. Similarly, the Warren Commission, which covered up the crime, redirects to a sub-sub-page: John F. Kennedy/Assassination/Cover-up.

Such standardised pagenames fulfill the role of binomial names in biology; existing in parallel with alternative common names, they provide an easily interpreted structure intended to help both software and humans in navigation around the pages, and could be used in conjunction with particular Semantic properties. Common subpage names include:

For events which feature a country name in the title (e.g. the 1953 Iranian coup d'état), best practice is to use a subpage, i.e. Iran/1953 coup d'état, since this is short, clear and more helpful to viewers of the parent page - Iran.

People's Names

The first mention of a page topic should be in bold, at of very near to the start of the lede paragraph. To help disambiguate individuals, and to clarify their establishment credentials, this mention should include all middle names, initials, and titles awarded (whether from birth or as a result of actions carried out). For simplicity, consistency and to redress credentialism, names of individuals should otherwise be devoid of titles.

Where people are commonly referred to by their title, a redirect page is fine. e.g. Colonel Gaddafi is a redirect to the main page, Muammar Gaddafi. This can be varied where a title has become integral to the name, e.g. "Dr Rola". This site supports Unicode, so for non-English names you should have no trouble using the appropriate accented characters (ä, Ç, ë...).

Disambiguation

Middle names and initials are generally deprecated, but provide one simple way to avoid ambiguity where people share the same first and last names, and are preferred to honorary titles for this purpose. Another option is to give a modifier in brackets after the name. Where only one other person shares the name, the lede should begin with a simple link in italics to the other page.[2]

Pseudonyms

Pseudonyms should be placed within single quotes. (e.g. 'Stakeknife')

Initials

Generally, middle initials should be avoided in titles, unless this is helpful either for clarity or to avoid ambiguity. When using initials, always use a dot after them, to distinguish them from one letter names (such as U Thant).

Names of books, films etc.

Since 2017, Wikispooks has recommended all names of publications should be in italics. This allows for easy disambiguation of otherwise identically named concepts. For example, Alan Francovich produced a film entitled Operation Gladio about the NATO Operation Gladio. Standards for the target page name are not set, but as usual it should be simple and clear (in this case, the italic text is a link to Operation Gladio (film)).

Singular/Plural

For consistency and clarity, page titles which are nouns should generally be given in the singular. So, the article about False Flag Attacks is actually entitled "False Flag Attack" - note that Mediawiki's link syntax means that this plurals can be easily linked like this: [[False Flag Attack]]s

Letter Case

Mediawiki automatically capitalizes the first letter of each pagename, but for multiple word titles, there is ambiguity about whether the other words should be capitalized or not. e.g. False Flag Attack or False flag attack? The standard is to use lower case where possible. Subpages should have an initial capital. This policy was only adopted in February 2014, so some older page names do not yet follow it.

Special Characters

Although this site has full support for unicode, not all other sites do, and since non-ascii characters can lead to unexpected results in some software,[3] it is good practice to use standard ascii unless alternatives yield a tangible benefit - so use of foreign accents is recommended for names because of increased accuracy, but a simple apostrophe or quote mark is preferred to the unicode variants.

Events with Dates

Many pagenames have dates for greater clarity or to avoid ambiguity (e.g. the 2003 Iraq war). Where a year is part of the title, it is recommended to put this first for consistency's sake, and also to help with sorting.

Other Names

Although none are as widely used or as important as page names, there are a host of other items for which standards would simplify and improve Wikispooks.

Categories

SMW is preferred over categories for organising content as it is more modern and flexible. There is a legacy category tree, but do not add categories to it or use categories. Categories are used however, for organising the templates which make up this site and the community portal.

Properties

Full article: Wikispooks:Semantic Properties

SMW uses relationships referred to as "Properties", most of which (but not all) have the form "Has something".

Templates

As with properties, these are mostly used 'behind the scenes', so templates don't impinge on the user experience, but standardisation is important to facilitate collaboration between those who create them.

Parameters

A standard for custom Wikispooks templates was fixed in June 2014, although it is not yet followed by all Wikispooks templates and is still subject to review. Parameter names should be :

  • all in lower case letters (although exceptions are possible, for clarity, e.g. "ON_" to differentiate official narratives)
  • connected by underscores (_) and not spaces where multiple words exist

This standard does not apply to templates are imported other websites.


Image size

There are no strict standards for image sizes, it is always a judgement call. Both aesthetic and — especially for small screen sizes — practical considerations apply. The commonest size is probably 300px. Where a page already has several images, copying one of their widths is often a good choice. Especially wide and/or important images may merit a greater width, especially if they are intended to stand alone rather than alongside text.

Redirects

If in doubt, more redirects is better than less. However, do check the correct spelling before you make a redirect. Creating lots of redirects for incorrect spellings is not generally useful. While it is good that users can follow the link, this obscures the fact that a red link is an easy way to spot the spelling mistake. It is important to avoid 'circular' redirects - ones which link back to the page.

Whitespace

Mediawiki markup allows some flexibility as regards use of spaces. This section, for example, is headed == Whitespace == but could equally be ==Whitespace== or even == Whitespace==. Since it is not displayed to the reader, it is generally not of importance, but is relevant to use of Special:ReplaceText. For templates parameters, the preferred standard is to start each parameter in column 1 and not to include extraneous spaces, so |description=... is preferred to |description =...[4]

Project links

The Mediawiki software automatically aliases the Project: namespace to the Wikispooks: namespace. This should be used in preference as it is more portable - or use the custom Template:WSLink.

Wikispooks logo.png Policy.png
Wikispooks
Policy
Wikispooks to do.png Tools2.png SMW.png Help.png