Difference between revisions of "Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media"
(Expand) |
|||
| (7 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{group | {{group | ||
|website=http://syriapropagandamedia.org | |website=http://syriapropagandamedia.org | ||
| − | |constitutes= | + | |constitutes=Propaganda research |
| + | |description=A group of UK academics that [[Piers Robinson]] convened due to a shared interest in [[Propaganda]] surrounding [[Syria]] | ||
|leaders= | |leaders= | ||
|image=Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media.png | |image=Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media.png | ||
| Line 9: | Line 10: | ||
|start= | |start= | ||
|headquarters= | |headquarters= | ||
| − | |founders=Piers Robinson | + | |founders=Piers Robinson |
| − | |members=Louis Allday, Oliver Boyd-Barrett, T.J. Coles, Tim Hayward, Divya Jha, Adam Larson, Jake Mason, Tara McCormack, Paul McKeigue, David Miller, Jan Oberg, Piers Robinson, Simone Rudolphi, Greg Simons, Florian Zollmann | + | |members=Louis Allday, Vanessa Beeley, Oliver Boyd-Barrett, T.J. Coles, Philip Hammond (academic), Tim Hayward, Divya Jha, Michael Kobs, Adam Larson, Jake Mason, Tara McCormack, Paul McKeigue, David Miller, Jan Oberg, Carmen Renieri, Piers Robinson, Simone Rudolphi, Greg Simons, Florian Zollmann |
| − | |||
}} | }} | ||
| − | The '''Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media''' is made up of [[academic]]s and PhD students from a variety of UK [[universities]]. | + | The '''Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media''' ('''SPM''') is made up of [[academic]]s and PhD students from a variety of UK [[universities]]. [[SPM]] was convened by [[Piers Robinson]] and is critical of the UK {{ccm}} reporting about [[Syria]], and has in turn been criticised by them. |
| − | == | + | ==Own words== |
| − | + | The SPM website declares that:<ref>http://syriapropagandamedia.org/about</ref> | |
| − | The | + | {{QB|This working group aims to facilitate research and debate with respect to the 2011-present war in [[Syria]] and the role of both media and [[propaganda]]. In all wars, truth and reality are profoundly contested whilst media frequently struggle to maintain independence and autonomy in the face of [[propaganda]] strategies pursued by combatants and participants, both internal and external. The war in [[Syria]] is no exception. At present there exists an urgent need for rigorous academic analysis of media reporting of this war, the role that [[propaganda]] has played in terms of shaping perceptions of the conflict and how these relate to broader geo-strategic process within the ME region and beyond. |
| − | {{QB|This working group aims to facilitate research and debate with respect to the 2011-present war in Syria and the role of both media and propaganda. In all wars, truth and reality are profoundly contested whilst media frequently struggle to maintain independence and autonomy in the face of propaganda strategies pursued by combatants and participants, both internal and external. The war in Syria is no exception. At present there exists an urgent need for rigorous academic analysis of media reporting of this war, the role that propaganda has played in terms of shaping perceptions of the conflict and how these relate to broader geo-strategic process within the ME region and beyond. | ||
With these needs in mind, this working group has been established in order to encourage networking amongst academics as well as the development of conference papers and panels, articles and research monographs, and the development of research funding bids. We also aim to provide a source of reliable, informed and timely analysis for journalists, publics and policymakers.}} | With these needs in mind, this working group has been established in order to encourage networking amongst academics as well as the development of conference papers and panels, articles and research monographs, and the development of research funding bids. We also aim to provide a source of reliable, informed and timely analysis for journalists, publics and policymakers.}} | ||
| + | [[SPM]] is part of the [[Organisation for Propaganda Studies]].<ref>http://propagandastudies.ac.uk/</ref><ref>https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/11076900/officers</ref> | ||
==Corporate media response== | ==Corporate media response== | ||
| − | [ | + | [[image:time_on_wgospam.jpg|right|300px|thumbnail|Front page of ''The Times'' on the morning [[US]] and [[UK]] forces were bombing in [[Syria]].]] |
| + | [[Brian Whitaker]], former [[Middle East]] editor of the ''[[Guardian]]'' wrote on 26 February 2018 that [[SPM]] (which then numbered three professors, two lecturers and three postgraduate researchers) seemed "more like a [[propaganda]] exercise than a serious academic project." | ||
| − | ''[[The Times]]'' wrote that the group was "spreading pro-Assad disinformation". Tim Hayward wrote that "a question thoughtful readers will likely be asking is why ''The Times'' has gone the trouble it has to give such prominence to a small group of critical academics." | + | Two days later [[Jonathan Cook]] wrote in an article entitled ''The Authoritarians Who Silence Syria Questions'' that [[Brian Whitaker|Whitaker]] was "using every ploy in the misdirection and circular logic playbook to discredit those who commit thought crimes on [[Syria]], by raising questions both about what is really happening there and about whether we can trust the [[corporate media]] consensus banging the regime-change drum."<ref>https://www.counterpunch.org/2018/02/28/the-authoritarians-who-silence-syria-questions/</ref> |
| + | |||
| + | ''[[The Times]]'' wrote that the group was "spreading pro-[[Assad]] disinformation". [[Tim Hayward]] wrote that "a question thoughtful readers will likely be asking is why ''The Times'' has gone to the trouble it has to give such prominence to a small group of critical academics." | ||
==Integrity Initiative== | ==Integrity Initiative== | ||
{{FA|Integrity Initiative}} | {{FA|Integrity Initiative}} | ||
| − | On 20 December 2019 [[Paul McKeigue]], [[David Miller]], [ | + | On 20 December 2019 [[Paul McKeigue]], [[David Miller]], [http://sana.sy/en/?tag=jake-mason Jake Mason] and [[Piers Robinson]], all of the Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media, published a [http://syriapropagandamedia.org/working-papers/briefing-note-on-the-integrity-initiative "Briefing note on the Integrity Initiative".]<ref>http://syriapropagandamedia.org/working-papers/briefing-note-on-the-integrity-initiative#appendix---list-of-documents-released-up-to-20-december-2018</ref> |
| + | |||
| + | ==BBC's Road To Damascus== | ||
| + | {{YouTubeVideo | ||
| + | |code=DEPKgCy2bbQ | ||
| + | |align=left | ||
| + | |width=300px | ||
| + | |caption=[[SPM]]'s [[Vanessa Beeley]] and [[Piers Robinson]] are interviewed by [[Ross Ashcroft]] | ||
| + | }} | ||
| + | [[Renegade Inc]] reports:{{QB|It is incredibly rare that the [[BBC]] ever admits that one of their reports on [[Douma]] in [[Syria]] failed to meet the Corporation's editorial standards for accuracy by reporting false claims… | ||
| + | |||
| + | Blink and you’d have missed this admission, but we didn’t, and it adds to a volley of misreporting that has dogged journalism and peace in the [[Middle East]] for decades. | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Ross Ashcroft]] is joined by political scientist Dr [[Piers Robinson]] and journalist [[Vanessa Beeley]] to discuss the crumbling narrative around the alleged [[Douma chemical attack]]. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The ''[[YouTube]]'' video concludes: | ||
| + | |||
| + | "We contacted the [[OPCW]], the [[BBC]] and [[Chloe Hadjimatheou]] about the issues raised in this programme. | ||
| + | |||
| + | "The [[BBC]] declined to comment. | ||
| + | |||
| + | "The [[OPCW]] did not respond. | ||
| + | |||
| + | "[[Chloe Hadjimatheou]] did not respond."<ref>''[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DEPKgCy2bbQ "Renegade Inc – The BBC's Road To Damascus"]''</ref>}} | ||
| + | |||
{{SMWDocs}} | {{SMWDocs}} | ||
==References== | ==References== | ||
{{reflist}} | {{reflist}} | ||
Latest revision as of 17:28, 4 March 2023
 Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media(Propaganda research)    | |
|---|---|
 The group's simple website design emphasises the devastation in Syria | |
| Founder |  Piers Robinson |
| Interests | Syria/Propaganda, Integrity Initiative, Skripal Affair, Institute for Statecraft, White Helmets |
| Membership | • Louis Allday •  Vanessa Beeley• Oliver Boyd-Barrett •  T.J. Coles•  Philip Hammond (academic)•  Tim Hayward• Divya Jha • Michael Kobs •  Adam Larson• Jake Mason • Tara McCormack • Paul McKeigue •  David Miller•  Jan Oberg• Carmen Renieri • Piers Robinson• Simone Rudolphi • Greg Simons • Florian Zollmann |
| A group of UK academics that Piers Robinson convened due to a shared interest in Propaganda surrounding Syria | |
The Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media (SPM) is made up of academics and PhD students from a variety of UK universities. SPM was convened by Piers Robinson and is critical of the UK commercially-controlled media reporting about Syria, and has in turn been criticised by them.
Contents
Own words
The SPM website declares that:[1]
This working group aims to facilitate research and debate with respect to the 2011-present war in Syria and the role of both media and propaganda. In all wars, truth and reality are profoundly contested whilst media frequently struggle to maintain independence and autonomy in the face of propaganda strategies pursued by combatants and participants, both internal and external. The war in Syria is no exception. At present there exists an urgent need for rigorous academic analysis of media reporting of this war, the role that propaganda has played in terms of shaping perceptions of the conflict and how these relate to broader geo-strategic process within the ME region and beyond. With these needs in mind, this working group has been established in order to encourage networking amongst academics as well as the development of conference papers and panels, articles and research monographs, and the development of research funding bids. We also aim to provide a source of reliable, informed and timely analysis for journalists, publics and policymakers.
SPM is part of the Organisation for Propaganda Studies.[2][3]
Corporate media response
Brian Whitaker, former Middle East editor of the Guardian wrote on 26 February 2018 that SPM (which then numbered three professors, two lecturers and three postgraduate researchers) seemed "more like a propaganda exercise than a serious academic project."
Two days later Jonathan Cook wrote in an article entitled The Authoritarians Who Silence Syria Questions that Whitaker was "using every ploy in the misdirection and circular logic playbook to discredit those who commit thought crimes on Syria, by raising questions both about what is really happening there and about whether we can trust the corporate media consensus banging the regime-change drum."[4]
The Times wrote that the group was "spreading pro-Assad disinformation". Tim Hayward wrote that "a question thoughtful readers will likely be asking is why The Times has gone to the trouble it has to give such prominence to a small group of critical academics."
Integrity Initiative
- Full article: Integrity Initiative
- Full article: Integrity Initiative
On 20 December 2019 Paul McKeigue, David Miller, Jake Mason and Piers Robinson, all of the Working Group on Syria Propaganda and Media, published a "Briefing note on the Integrity Initiative".[5]
BBC's Road To Damascus
| SPM's Vanessa Beeley and Piers Robinson are interviewed by Ross Ashcroft |
Renegade Inc reports:
It is incredibly rare that the BBC ever admits that one of their reports on Douma in Syria failed to meet the Corporation's editorial standards for accuracy by reporting false claims…
Blink and you’d have missed this admission, but we didn’t, and it adds to a volley of misreporting that has dogged journalism and peace in the Middle East for decades.
Ross Ashcroft is joined by political scientist Dr Piers Robinson and journalist Vanessa Beeley to discuss the crumbling narrative around the alleged Douma chemical attack.
The YouTube video concludes:
"We contacted the OPCW, the BBC and Chloe Hadjimatheou about the issues raised in this programme.
"The BBC declined to comment.
"The OPCW did not respond.
"Chloe Hadjimatheou did not respond."[6]
Known members
8 of the 19 of the members already have pages here:
| Member | Description |
|---|---|
| Vanessa Beeley | British investigative journalist focused on the Middle East. Helped expose the White Helmets. |
| Philip Hammond (academic) | |
| Tim Hayward | |
| Adam Larson | |
| Paul McKeigue | |
| David Miller | Founder of Powerbase & Spinwatch and incisive anti-Zionist reporter on world affairs |
| Piers Robinson | One of "Assad's Useful Idiots", a deep political researcher, founded the Working Group on Propaganda and the 9/11 global "War on Terror" |
| Jan Øberg | Danish/Swedish peace researcher |
References
- ↑ http://syriapropagandamedia.org/about
- ↑ http://propagandastudies.ac.uk/
- ↑ https://beta.companieshouse.gov.uk/company/11076900/officers
- ↑ https://www.counterpunch.org/2018/02/28/the-authoritarians-who-silence-syria-questions/
- ↑ http://syriapropagandamedia.org/working-papers/briefing-note-on-the-integrity-initiative#appendix---list-of-documents-released-up-to-20-december-2018
- ↑ "Renegade Inc – The BBC's Road To Damascus"
