Difference between revisions of "Tackling Tools of Malign Influence"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Created page with "Peter Pomerantsev, Ida Eklund Lindwall, Jessikka Aro, Guillaume Chaslot, Alina Polyakova, Michał Boni, Andy Pryce, Daniel Fried, Brian Maguire {{event |wikipedia= |image=Ta...") |
(expand participants) |
||
| (8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
{{event | {{event | ||
|wikipedia= | |wikipedia= | ||
| Line 9: | Line 6: | ||
|locations=Frontline Club, London | |locations=Frontline Club, London | ||
|URL= | |URL= | ||
| + | |interests=fake news, Russian propaganda | ||
| + | |description=[[Integrity Initiative]] conference about "[[Russian Propaganda]]" | ||
| + | |planners=Integrity Initiative | ||
|constitutes=conference | |constitutes=conference | ||
| − | |participants=Natalia Antaleva, James Ball, Carole Cadwalladr, Stephen Dalziel, Ben Nimmo, Dean Nelson, Taha Siddiqui, Alex Spillius, Andrew Taylor, Dimitris Xenakis | + | |participants=David Aaronovitch, Natalia Antaleva, James Ball, Heidi Blake, Ingrid Brodnig, Carole Cadwalladr, Nick Cohen, Stephen Dalziel, Lindsey Hilsum, James Landale, Damien McElroy, Dean Nelson, Marc Margenidas, Ben Nimmo, Dean Nelson, Tunca Ogreten, Gideon Rachman, Laurent Richard, Luba Rizova, Kim Sengupta, Taha Siddiqui, Alex Spillius, Andrew Taylor, Dimitris Xenakis |
}} | }} | ||
| − | '''Tackling Tools of Malign Influence - Supporting 21st Century Journalism''' was a [[conference held from 1-2 | + | '''''Tackling Tools of Malign Influence - Supporting 21st Century Journalism''''' was a [[conference]] held from 1-2 November 2018 by the [[Integrity Initiative]] - possibly the last such conference before the group was exposed by [['Anonymous']] on 5 November. The primary source for this page is a PDF of the draft agenda.<ref>https://www.pdf-archive.com/2018/12/13/skillsharingdraft-nov12/skillsharingdraft-nov12.pdf</ref> |
==Agenda== | ==Agenda== | ||
| − | The draft agenda was leaked. | + | The draft agenda was leaked: |
| + | {{QB| | ||
| + | The challenges are manifold: from [[fake news]] and misinformation campaigns to state-sponsored harassment and intimidation and violence; from commercial pressures and lack of resources to a relentless social and digital media environment. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Across [[Europe]] and the Mediterranean, the threat to independent journalism is spreading, with mass detentions in [[Turkey]], a murder in Malta and revelations on how fake news targeted voters in the UK’s Brexit referendum all underlining the need for vigilance. So how can journalists hold power to account in the face of these challenges? How can honest, fair and independent journalism be nurtured and sustained? Over the course of two days at the Frontline Club, the conference will take a detailed look at the various threats to public interest journalism and what can be done to resist them. It will bring together experienced journalists from the region who have survived [[kidnapping]], death threats, harassment or arrest, with young journalists from countries where reporting freedoms are under threat. They will be joined by renowned foreign correspondents and investigative journalists from the UK for a frank and intimate discussion about their experiences and the coping methods necessary to survive and continue doing their jobs. Our aim is that these conversations will guide future practical support services to furnish journalists working in difficult environments with the means to develop and sustain their ability to report on public interest issues without fear or favour. | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
===1 November=== | ===1 November=== | ||
* 14:00-14:15 Opening Remarks: [[Stephen Dalziel]], Institute of Statecraft, the need to support integrity journalism. Foreign Desk director on the conference agenda and goals | * 14:00-14:15 Opening Remarks: [[Stephen Dalziel]], Institute of Statecraft, the need to support integrity journalism. Foreign Desk director on the conference agenda and goals | ||
| − | * 14:20-15:30 Discussion + Q&A: The Fake News Challenge to Independent Journalism Misinformation has been deployed as an instrument of conflict in Ukraine, to undermine elections and referendums in the United States and United Kingdom, and more widely as a tool to erode trust in established professional media organisations. How has the Russian state used fake news as an aggressor state; what are its methods, are they changing, what are its goals? | + | * 14:20-15:30 Discussion + Q&A: The Fake News Challenge to Independent Journalism Misinformation has been deployed as an instrument of conflict in Ukraine, to undermine elections and referendums in the United States and United Kingdom, and more widely as a tool to erode trust in established professional media organisations. How has the Russian state used [[fake news]] as an aggressor state; what are its methods, are they changing, what are its goals? |
Ukrainian speaker from [[StopFake]] or [[Detektor]] on how Russian misinformation was weaponised as an instrument of war in the country’s civil conflict | Ukrainian speaker from [[StopFake]] or [[Detektor]] on how Russian misinformation was weaponised as an instrument of war in the country’s civil conflict | ||
| − | [[Natalia Antaleva]], former BBC correspondent and founder of CodaStory. Based in Tblisi, she is expert in fake news and state repression of independent media across Ukraine and the CIS countries. | + | [[Natalia Antaleva]], former BBC correspondent and founder of [[CodaStory]]. Based in Tblisi, she is expert in fake news and state repression of independent media across Ukraine and the CIS countries. |
[[Carole Cadwalladr]], ''[[Observer]]'' [[journalist]] who has broken several exclusive stories on how [[Facebook]] allowed [[Cambridge Analytica]] to steal private data and the [[Vote Leave]] campaign to disseminate misinformation to skew the [[Brexit]] referendum Moderator: [[Dean Nelson]] ,FD Director, former ''[[Sunday Times]]'' Insight Editor | [[Carole Cadwalladr]], ''[[Observer]]'' [[journalist]] who has broken several exclusive stories on how [[Facebook]] allowed [[Cambridge Analytica]] to steal private data and the [[Vote Leave]] campaign to disseminate misinformation to skew the [[Brexit]] referendum Moderator: [[Dean Nelson]] ,FD Director, former ''[[Sunday Times]]'' Insight Editor | ||
| Line 43: | Line 44: | ||
How political and security establishments use legal and extra-judicial means to suppress information and bully journalists to toe the line. | How political and security establishments use legal and extra-judicial means to suppress information and bully journalists to toe the line. | ||
| − | [[Laurent Richard]] of Forbidden Stories, or Relative/Colleague of [[Daphne Caruana Galizia]], the Maltese journalist killed last year over her investigations into money laundering and corruption in the country [[Tunca Ogreten]], Turkish journalist who was locked up for 11 months for reports on Erdogan’s son-in-law and minister Berat Albayrak, or [[Murat Sabuncu]], Cumhurriyet editor, jailed for a year for ‘terror’ related charges of reporting on activities of PKK and Gulen. Frederica Jansz | + | [[Laurent Richard]] of [[Forbidden Stories]], or Relative/Colleague of [[Daphne Caruana Galizia]], the Maltese journalist killed last year over her investigations into money laundering and corruption in the country [[Tunca Ogreten]], Turkish journalist who was locked up for 11 months for reports on Erdogan’s son-in-law and minister [[Berat Albayrak]], or [[Murat Sabuncu]], Cumhurriyet editor, jailed for a year for ‘terror’ related charges of reporting on activities of PKK and [[Gulen]]. [[Frederica Jansz]] – former editor of [[Sri Lanka]]'s ''Sunday Leader''. Dismissed in 2012 by a new, government-friendly owner, and forced to flee the country under US protection amid death threats. She will join by video-link from her home in Seattle. |
| + | |||
| + | Moderator: [[Damien McElroy]], [[Foreign Desk]] director, war correspondent | ||
| + | |||
| + | * 18.30-19.15 Networking drinks and journalist briefing [[Tunca Ogreten]] roundtable with UK journalists (e.g. [[Nick Cohen]], [[David Aaronovitch]], [[Kim Sengupta]], [[Gideon Rachman]], [[Lindsey Hilsum]], [[James Landale]]) | ||
| + | * 19.45-close Dinner + Speaker: [[Nick Cohen|NICK COHEN]] - Why accuracy, fairness and balance are essential to independent journalism (back up: Christiane Amanpour, Alex Crawford) November 2, 2018 9-10.10 (UK journalism students join) Discussion + Q&A: Compromising the Owner/Editor –Influence in the Media Andras Muranyi, editor of Népszabadság, Hungary’s left-leaning newspaper and best-selling political daily, which was suspended and then sold to an ally of [[Viktor Orban]]. | ||
[[Luba Rizova]], former news director of BTV in [[Bulgaria]], the country’s most successful private channel, explains how constant political pressure and threats from politicians and oligarchs is causing journalists to quit or practice [[self-censorship]]. | [[Luba Rizova]], former news director of BTV in [[Bulgaria]], the country’s most successful private channel, explains how constant political pressure and threats from politicians and oligarchs is causing journalists to quit or practice [[self-censorship]]. | ||
| − | [[Dimitris Xenakis]], managing editor of Inside Story, one of two independent investigative websites in Greece, explains how Greek journalists have lost their ability to pursue a story amid political and financial pressure. | + | [[Dimitris Xenakis]], managing editor of ''[[Inside Story]]'', one of two independent investigative websites in [[Greece]], explains how Greek journalists have lost their ability to pursue a story amid political and financial pressure. |
Moderator: [[Alex Spillius]], FD director and former diplomatic correspondent, ''[[Daily Telegraph ]]'' | Moderator: [[Alex Spillius]], FD director and former diplomatic correspondent, ''[[Daily Telegraph ]]'' | ||
===2 November=== | ===2 November=== | ||
| − | + | * 10:20-11:40 | |
| + | ** Breakout session: ''Digital Safety – Protecting your data or story from prying eyes'' [[Andrew Taylor]], former [[GCHQ]] cyber expert on how to keep one step ahead in safeguarding your material and sources from being intercepted by those who mean you harm. | ||
| + | [[Ingrid Brodnig]], Austrian journalist turned expert on digital harassment and algorithms. | ||
| + | ** Breakout session: ''How to beat the trap and face down the system when pressure mounts'' [[Taha Siddiqui]] – renowned Pakistani journalist who escaped from an attempted kidnapping earlier this year and now lives in exile in [[Paris]]. [[StopFake]] on how they have fought back against misinformation and censorship in Ukraine | ||
| + | |||
| + | * 11.50-13.00 Investigative masterclass How to build an investigation, develop trust with sources, obtain documentary support, maintain balance in your reporting, keep the momentum going over an extended period. | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Heidi Blake]], investigations editor of [[Buzzfeed]], who led an in-depth exposé of the hushing up of the murder of Kremlin enemies in Britain. Moderator: [[Dean Nelson]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | * 13:00-13:45 Closing remarks: resistance and resilience Amid the unprecedented challenges of misinformation and rising violence and intimidation, let’s remind ourselves why journalists keep going, and they need to keep going. [[Marc Margenidas]] correspondent of ''[[El Periodico de Catalunya]]'' in Moscow, has a long career both in Russia and MENA (including the terrible experience of being captive of ISIS for 6-months) | ||
| + | }} | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | ==See also== | ||
| + | [[Document:Journalism skill sharing seminar]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Document:Independent journalism in hostile places or How to report Repressive Regimes and survive]] | ||
| + | |||
{{SMWDocs}} | {{SMWDocs}} | ||
| + | |||
==References== | ==References== | ||
{{reflist}} | {{reflist}} | ||
| − | |||
Latest revision as of 03:03, 1 June 2023
 | |
| Date | 1 November 2018 - 2 November 2018 |
|---|---|
| Location | Frontline Club, London |
| Planners | Integrity Initiative |
| Participants | David Aaronovitch, Natalia Antaleva, James Ball, Heidi Blake, Ingrid Brodnig, Carole Cadwalladr, Nick Cohen, Stephen Dalziel, Lindsey Hilsum, James Landale, Damien McElroy, Dean Nelson, Marc Margenidas, Ben Nimmo, Dean Nelson, Tunca Ogreten, Gideon Rachman, Laurent Richard, Luba Rizova, Kim Sengupta, Taha Siddiqui, Alex Spillius, Andrew Taylor, Dimitris Xenakis |
| Interests | • fake news • Russian propaganda |
| Description | Integrity Initiative conference about "Russian Propaganda" |
Tackling Tools of Malign Influence - Supporting 21st Century Journalism was a conference held from 1-2 November 2018 by the Integrity Initiative - possibly the last such conference before the group was exposed by 'Anonymous' on 5 November. The primary source for this page is a PDF of the draft agenda.[1]
Contents
Agenda
The draft agenda was leaked:
The challenges are manifold: from fake news and misinformation campaigns to state-sponsored harassment and intimidation and violence; from commercial pressures and lack of resources to a relentless social and digital media environment.
Across Europe and the Mediterranean, the threat to independent journalism is spreading, with mass detentions in Turkey, a murder in Malta and revelations on how fake news targeted voters in the UK’s Brexit referendum all underlining the need for vigilance. So how can journalists hold power to account in the face of these challenges? How can honest, fair and independent journalism be nurtured and sustained? Over the course of two days at the Frontline Club, the conference will take a detailed look at the various threats to public interest journalism and what can be done to resist them. It will bring together experienced journalists from the region who have survived kidnapping, death threats, harassment or arrest, with young journalists from countries where reporting freedoms are under threat. They will be joined by renowned foreign correspondents and investigative journalists from the UK for a frank and intimate discussion about their experiences and the coping methods necessary to survive and continue doing their jobs. Our aim is that these conversations will guide future practical support services to furnish journalists working in difficult environments with the means to develop and sustain their ability to report on public interest issues without fear or favour.
1 November
- 14:00-14:15 Opening Remarks: Stephen Dalziel, Institute of Statecraft, the need to support integrity journalism. Foreign Desk director on the conference agenda and goals
- 14:20-15:30 Discussion + Q&A: The Fake News Challenge to Independent Journalism Misinformation has been deployed as an instrument of conflict in Ukraine, to undermine elections and referendums in the United States and United Kingdom, and more widely as a tool to erode trust in established professional media organisations. How has the Russian state used fake news as an aggressor state; what are its methods, are they changing, what are its goals?
Ukrainian speaker from StopFake or Detektor on how Russian misinformation was weaponised as an instrument of war in the country’s civil conflict
Natalia Antaleva, former BBC correspondent and founder of CodaStory. Based in Tblisi, she is expert in fake news and state repression of independent media across Ukraine and the CIS countries.
Carole Cadwalladr, Observer journalist who has broken several exclusive stories on how Facebook allowed Cambridge Analytica to steal private data and the Vote Leave campaign to disseminate misinformation to skew the Brexit referendum Moderator: Dean Nelson ,FD Director, former Sunday Times Insight Editor
Coffee break
Breakout sessions: Dealing with the Fake News Challenge Ben Nimmo, Atlantic Council and Institute of Statecraft analyst on disinformation, on How to Spot a Bot – identifying fake accounts and the misinformation they spread.
James Ball, Buzzfeed journalist, former Guardian and WikiLeaks researcher, author of How Bullshit Conquered the World: Fighting Fake News in the newsroom - how Buzzfeed does it.
Natalia Antaleva: Independent Journalism is the Antidote to Misinformation –but you need to stay with the story StopFake on how Ukraine has worked to check misinformation, successes and failures.
- 17:05-18:15 Discussion + Q&A: Harassment, Intimidation and Murder: The War on Truth
How political and security establishments use legal and extra-judicial means to suppress information and bully journalists to toe the line.
Laurent Richard of Forbidden Stories, or Relative/Colleague of Daphne Caruana Galizia, the Maltese journalist killed last year over her investigations into money laundering and corruption in the country Tunca Ogreten, Turkish journalist who was locked up for 11 months for reports on Erdogan’s son-in-law and minister Berat Albayrak, or Murat Sabuncu, Cumhurriyet editor, jailed for a year for ‘terror’ related charges of reporting on activities of PKK and Gulen. Frederica Jansz – former editor of Sri Lanka's Sunday Leader. Dismissed in 2012 by a new, government-friendly owner, and forced to flee the country under US protection amid death threats. She will join by video-link from her home in Seattle.
Moderator: Damien McElroy, Foreign Desk director, war correspondent
- 18.30-19.15 Networking drinks and journalist briefing Tunca Ogreten roundtable with UK journalists (e.g. Nick Cohen, David Aaronovitch, Kim Sengupta, Gideon Rachman, Lindsey Hilsum, James Landale)
- 19.45-close Dinner + Speaker: NICK COHEN - Why accuracy, fairness and balance are essential to independent journalism (back up: Christiane Amanpour, Alex Crawford) November 2, 2018 9-10.10 (UK journalism students join) Discussion + Q&A: Compromising the Owner/Editor –Influence in the Media Andras Muranyi, editor of Népszabadság, Hungary’s left-leaning newspaper and best-selling political daily, which was suspended and then sold to an ally of Viktor Orban.
Luba Rizova, former news director of BTV in Bulgaria, the country’s most successful private channel, explains how constant political pressure and threats from politicians and oligarchs is causing journalists to quit or practice self-censorship.
Dimitris Xenakis, managing editor of Inside Story, one of two independent investigative websites in Greece, explains how Greek journalists have lost their ability to pursue a story amid political and financial pressure. Moderator: Alex Spillius, FD director and former diplomatic correspondent, Daily Telegraph
2 November
- 10:20-11:40
- Breakout session: Digital Safety – Protecting your data or story from prying eyes Andrew Taylor, former GCHQ cyber expert on how to keep one step ahead in safeguarding your material and sources from being intercepted by those who mean you harm.
Ingrid Brodnig, Austrian journalist turned expert on digital harassment and algorithms.
- Breakout session: How to beat the trap and face down the system when pressure mounts Taha Siddiqui – renowned Pakistani journalist who escaped from an attempted kidnapping earlier this year and now lives in exile in Paris. StopFake on how they have fought back against misinformation and censorship in Ukraine
- 11.50-13.00 Investigative masterclass How to build an investigation, develop trust with sources, obtain documentary support, maintain balance in your reporting, keep the momentum going over an extended period.
Heidi Blake, investigations editor of Buzzfeed, who led an in-depth exposé of the hushing up of the murder of Kremlin enemies in Britain. Moderator: Dean Nelson
- 13:00-13:45 Closing remarks: resistance and resilience Amid the unprecedented challenges of misinformation and rising violence and intimidation, let’s remind ourselves why journalists keep going, and they need to keep going. Marc Margenidas correspondent of El Periodico de Catalunya in Moscow, has a long career both in Russia and MENA (including the terrible experience of being captive of ISIS for 6-months)
See also
Document:Journalism skill sharing seminar
Document:Independent journalism in hostile places or How to report Repressive Regimes and survive
Known Participants
16 of the 23 of the participants already have pages here:
| Participant | Description |
|---|---|
| David Aaronovitch | UK deep state propagandist on topics from the Bilderberg group to the UK COVID-19 Lockdown. Denied being connected to the Integrity Initiative although leaked documents included his name. |
| James Ball | UK journalist and author who worked for the Integrity Initiative |
| Heidi Blake | Journalist who took part in the II linked Tackling Tools of Malign Influence conference |
| Ingrid Brodnig | Austrian journalist who was at the II-backed Tackling Tools of Malign Influence meeting |
| Carole Cadwalladr | Journalist who took part in an IfS presentation about "Russian Propaganda". Rose to international prominence in 2018 when she exposed the Facebook-Cambridge Analytica data scandal. |
| Nick Cohen | Establishment journalist who spoke at Tackling Tools of Malign Influence, an Integrity Initiative sponsored conference |
| Stephen Dalziel | Spokesman for the Institute for Statecraft and "Research and Staff Coordinator" of the Integrity Initiative with "Forty years of dealing with Russia"... “Definitely not secret service, I promise you.” Russo-British Chamber of Commerce director |
| Lindsey Hilsum | UK journalist who was at the II-backed Tackling Tools of Malign Influence meeting |
| James Landale | The BBC's diplomatic correspondent |
| Damien McElroy | Journalist who spoke at an Integrity Initiative conference on "Russian Propaganda". |
| Dean Nelson | Editor who moderated a a section of an II conference. |
| Ben Nimmo | "Nimmo is a former spokesperson for NATO, who has essentially dedicated his career to fear-mongering about Russia." |
| Gideon Rachman | Quad Bilderberg UK journalist and friend of MI6 whistleblower Richard Tomlinson |
| Taha Siddiqui | Pakistani journalist who spoke at Tackling Tools of Malign Influence, an Integrity Initiative sponsored conference |
| Alex Spillius | UK journalist who attended the Integrity Initiative's Tackling Tools of Malign Influence, a few days before the II was exposed. |
| Dimitris Xenakis | Greek academic, employee of the Hellenic Ministry of National Defence, who spoke at Tackling Tools of Malign Influence, an Integrity Initiative sponsored conference. Denied membership of the Integrity Initiative's Greek Cluster. despite the documentary evidence. |
Related Document
| Title | Type | Publication date | Author(s) | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Document:Draft agenda for the conference Tackling Tools of Malign Influence | conference plan | Chris Donnelly | Draft conference plan for the Tackling Tools of Malign Influence event |
Many thanks to our Patrons who cover ~2/3 of our hosting bill. Please join them if you can.
