Historical revision

From Wikispooks
Jump to: navigation, search
Concept.png Historical revision Rdf-icon.png
Type idea

Historical revision is a continuous process involving the re-interpretation and modification of existing historical narratives in light of new or otherwise unknown, hidden or even suppressed evidence. As an academic discipline, it ought to be uncontroversial. However, in matters deemed potentially threatening by and to existing power structures, it can become very controversial indeed; so much so that there are Official Narrative's of major events which can only be questioned on pain of official opprobrium with all its attendant status and career risks.

The pre-eminent current (2012) example in this category is "The Holocaust". However, the entire history of the 20th century, particularly as it relates to the foreign policies of the victorious allied power of world wars I and II, is still ripe for substantial revision as more and more hitherto secret archive and other hidden and suppressed material becomes available to enterprising and brave historians.

The need for historical revision

“He who controls the past controls the future. He who controls the present controls the past.” — George Orwell, 1984


Howard Zinn Explains the importance of real history

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." - a George Santaya adage [1] plagiarised into many variants - is a useful encapsulation of the problem facing those who question Official Narrative's (histories).

By definition, Official Narrative's are always misleading, in service as they are to the powerful interests that they are held to legitimise - the bigger the interest, the bigger the misleading. And so it is with the biggest of all such interests: the victors' version of the who, what, how and why of war. ANYONE deemed a threat or looming challenge to such a narrative will inevitably meet the full power and force of its beneficiaries and those with emotional or other investment in it; more often than not such a person will be either destroyed or effectively silenced by the encounter. Intelligent, career-minded academic historians are acutely aware of all this and behave accordingly.

The following extract from James Hartfield's "Unpatriotic History of the Second World war" explains both the problem for would-be revisionists and the pressing need for them:

The official version of the history of the Second World War, and the more politicised ‘People’s War’ legend are profoundly ideological. They are in fact examples of ‘Victor’s History’ – as the Nuremberg and Tokyo War Trials were ‘Victor’s Justice’. They are ideological because they focus all criticism upon the Axis powers, and suspend judgment on the Allies. In these official versions of the Just War and the People’s War, the deaths of millions are justified for the greater good of ridding the world of dictatorship and militarism – even though the outcome of the war was the imposition of militaristic dictatorships over much of eastern Europe, the stabilisation of Fascist dictatorships in Spain and Portugal, the subjugation of millions to military rule in East Asia, and indeed in Germany. In the official version of history the atrocities carried out by the Axis powers come to be the emblematic features of the war, while those carried out by the Allies are dismissed as exceptional episodes, or even justified as the cruelties necessary to bring the war to a speedy conclusion. In the official version only the Axis powers have self-serving interests, while the Allies are motivated by moral exigencies. Racial supremacism and imperialist domination are faults that are never seen in the Allies.

The official version of the Allied War effort is so profoundly ideological that it violently misrepresents almost all aspects of the war. The official version is twisted and stretched to give the most extraordinary explanations of events that are quite easy to account for without it. To believe the official version, one must believe that the Atomic bomb saves lives; that the aerial bombardment of Germany was aimed at military targets; that the Nazis killed the Polish officers at Katyn though it was under Soviet rule at the time; that the Allies fought the war to save the Jews; that the Allied invasions of Iraq, Iran, Syria, Poland, Czechoslovakia, Greece, Vietnam, Korea and Indonesia were ‘liberations’. The truth creaks and strains under the constraints of the official version of the Second World War, and will keep breaking out, as evidence that there is more than is accounted for in the set texts. [2]

 

Examples

     Page name     TypeDateAuthor(s)Subject(s)Description
A Brief History of Forensic Examinations of AuschwitzarticleMarch 2001Germar RudolfAuschwitz
The Holocaust
A review of the the series of forensic examinations of the Auschwitz concentration camp alleged gas chambers that began with The Leuchter report and ended with the imprisonment in Germany of this author for authoring a similar though more rigorous report that was published without his authority
Commission for the Relief of Belgium 1article5 August 2015Jim Macgregor
Gerry Docherty
World War I
Commission for Relief in Belgium
The organisation, promotion and diversion of Belgian 'relief funding' for the hidden but nonetheless express purpose of prolonging the war
Commission for the Relief of Belgium 2article12 August 2015Jim Macgregor
Gerry Docherty
World War I
Commission for Relief in Belgium
Herbert Hoover
The organisation, promotion and diversion of Belgian 'relief funding' for the hidden but nonetheless express purpose of prolonging WW1.
Conjuring Hitler - Chapter 6book extract2005Guido PreparataWorld War II
Adolf Hitler
The Great Game
The concluding chapter of Guido Preparata's seminal work of World War II historical revision - Conjuring Hitler
Conjuring Hitler - Four years onarticle5 November 2008Guido PreparataWorld War II
Adolf Hitler
The Great Game
Guido Preparata's afterword to "Conjuring Hitler", his seminal work on the origins of World War II. It was written to mark publication of the book in German, some four years after the original English edition. Rueful insights into the academic suppression of work which challenges the rigidly enforced victors' orthodox narrative of the greatest man-made humanitarian disaster in history.
Hidden Historybook30 August 2013Gerry Docherty
Jim Macgregor
World War I
Historical revision
A meticulously researched tour de force on the hidden and suppressed history of the origins of World War I. The book will be very uncomfortable reading for anyone schooled in the Western Establishment Victor's history of the 20th century.
Other LossesbookJames BacqueWorld War IIAn expose of allied war crimes as regards treatment of prisoners.
File:TheRudolfReport.pdfeBook2003Germar RudolfThe Holocaust
Auschwitz
A science-based forensic examination of the alleged homicidal gas chambers of Auschwitz.
 

Related Documents

TitleTypePublication dateAuthor(s)Description
Hidden Historybook30 August 2013Gerry Docherty
Jim Macgregor
A meticulously researched tour de force on the hidden and suppressed history of the origins of World War I. The book will be very uncomfortable reading for anyone schooled in the Western Establishment Victor's history of the 20th century.
The Jewish role in the early Soviet Regimebook extract1 January 1921Robert WiltonDetails of the domination of the Bolshevik Party and early Soviet government by Jews - mostly non-Russian. The information was published in the 1921 French edition of the book but not in the original 1920 American and English editions. the information remains largely suppressed, obfuscated and 'politically incorrect'.
File:Truth for Germany.pdfeBook1965Udo WalendyScholarly questioning of the official (victor's) narrative of World War II as "The Peoples' War" or "The Good War". A narrative that is quintessentially ideological in laying blame for the biggest humanitarian catastrophe in history to date on Germany alone. The book, together with his subsequent publishing activities in the field of historical revision have earned this meek and self-effacing man one term of imprisonment and several other convictions in 'Freedom-loving' Germany.


57px-Notepad icon.png This is a page stub. Please add to it.


References

  1. George Santayana - Wikiquote
  2. Unpatriotic History of the Second World war by James Hartfield October 2012, John Hunt Publishing. ISBN 1780993781