Difference between revisions of "Hand in Hand for Syria"
(accounting non-filing) |
(|ON_constitutes=Charity) |
||
| (18 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
|start=2011 | |start=2011 | ||
|website=http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk | |website=http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk | ||
| + | |ON_constitutes=Charity | ||
| + | |facebook=https://www.facebook.com/handinhandsforsyria | ||
|logo=HiHLogo.jpg | |logo=HiHLogo.jpg | ||
| − | |description=The organisation that "Dr Rola" was working for when she called for humanitarian bombing of Syria. | + | |description=The spooky organisation that "[[Dr Rola]]" was working for when she called for humanitarian bombing of Syria. Now renamed and operating also in Turkey and Jordan. |
| − | |members= | + | |members=Faddy Sahloul, Razan Sahloul, Fadi Al-Dairi, Omar Abdul Gabbar, Nada Alkordi, Razan Zehrawi, Talaat Atassi, Rola Hallam, Raid Atassi, Manhal Alnasser, Basim Rahbi |
| − | |twitter=hands4Syr | + | |twitter=https://twitter.com/hands4Syr |
| + | |founders=Faddy Sahloul, Razan Sahloul, Fadi Al-Dairi | ||
|facebook=https://www.facebook.com/handinhandsforsyria | |facebook=https://www.facebook.com/handinhandsforsyria | ||
}} | }} | ||
| − | '''Hand in Hand for | + | '''Hand in Hand for Aid And Development''' is a UK registered charity incorporated on 13 February 2012 as '''Hand in Hand for Syria'''<ref name="cc">[http://apps.charitycommission.gov.uk/Showcharity/RegisterOfCharities/PrintReport.aspx?RegisteredCharityNumber=1145862&ReportType=BW Charity Commission] - Statutory information on 'Hand-in-Hand-for-Syria' at 29 June 2014</ref> and [http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk/ its web site] was set up on 1 March 2012. Channel 4 reports that it was "formed from within the Syrian diaspora [in 2012] in response to a deteriorating humanitarian crisis in the region"<ref name="C4">[http://www.channel4.com/news/syria-where-medicine-is-a-weapon-of-war Syria - where medicine is a weapon of war], Channel 4 report of Jan 23, 2013</ref>. The organisation came to prominence through "[[Dr Rola]] (Hallam)", who was apparently working as a volunteer during an alleged Napalm attack on a school in the village of Orum Alkubra in Aleppo on 26 August 2013.<ref name="HIH">[http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk/ Hand in Hand for Syria] - Home page</ref> In 2017 it was chosen as "Charity Of The Year" by the [[Muslim Charities Forum]].<ref>https://www.civilsociety.co.uk/news/hand-in-hand-for-syria-wins-overall-award-at-the-mcf-awards.html</ref> |
==Official Narrative== | ==Official Narrative== | ||
| − | Their [[Facebook]] page | + | Their [[Facebook]] page described Hand in Hand for Syria as a "UK Registered charity providing humanitarian support for the people of [[Syria]]." Their website states that they work wth the "UN’s OCHA (Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Affairs) to plan the distribution of aid."<ref>http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk/what-we-do/partners</ref> By September 2016, they were working in [[Jordan]], [[Syria]] and [[Turkey]].<ref>http://apps.charitycommission.gov.uk/Showcharity/RegisterOfCharities/PrintReport.aspx?RegisteredCharityNumber=1145862&ReportType=BW%20Charity%20Commission</ref> |
| − | |||
| − | [[ | ||
===Problems=== | ===Problems=== | ||
According to the UK charity commission, "an organisation cannot be a charity if it has a 'political purpose'."<ref name="CharityCommission">[http://www.charitycommission.gov.uk/detailed-guidance/registering-a-charity/what-makes-a-charity-cc4/annex-b-about-political-purposes UK Charity Commission, What Makes a Charity? Annex B - Political Purposes]</ref> As a UK charity, Hand in Hand for Syria is therefore explicitly prohibited from "furthering the interests of a particular political party" or from "securing or opposing any change in the law, whether in the UK or overseas".<ref name="CharityCommission"/> | According to the UK charity commission, "an organisation cannot be a charity if it has a 'political purpose'."<ref name="CharityCommission">[http://www.charitycommission.gov.uk/detailed-guidance/registering-a-charity/what-makes-a-charity-cc4/annex-b-about-political-purposes UK Charity Commission, What Makes a Charity? Annex B - Political Purposes]</ref> As a UK charity, Hand in Hand for Syria is therefore explicitly prohibited from "furthering the interests of a particular political party" or from "securing or opposing any change in the law, whether in the UK or overseas".<ref name="CharityCommission"/> | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
===Logo=== | ===Logo=== | ||
| − | As in the case of [[World for Libya]], | + | [[File:HiHLogoPlusName.png|thumb|Original logo|220px|left]] |
| + | [[File:SNOFlag.png|thumb|220px|Flag of the Syrian Nation Opposition]] | ||
| + | [[File:HiHLogoPlusNameNew.png|thumb|Revised logo|220px|left]]As in the case of [[World for Libya]], the charity's logo is clearly intended to display a political affiliation. (See the flag of the Syrian National Opposition - ''right, above''). Both supposedly non-political groups aligned themselves with the aims of the rebel groups. In Spring 2014, when their website was updated, the logo was quietly modified to remove the three red stars and the globe, but the affiliation remains indisputable. | ||
===Name=== | ===Name=== | ||
| Line 29: | Line 30: | ||
... We announce the formation of the free Syrian army to work '''hand in hand''' with the people to achieve freedom and dignity to bring this regime down, protect the revolution and the country’s resources, and stand in the face of the irresponsible military machine that protects the regime.”<ref>[http://www.aawsat.net/2011/08/article55245595 FSA Founding Statement] - Asharq al-Awsat web site, accessed 1 October 2013</ref>}} | ... We announce the formation of the free Syrian army to work '''hand in hand''' with the people to achieve freedom and dignity to bring this regime down, protect the revolution and the country’s resources, and stand in the face of the irresponsible military machine that protects the regime.”<ref>[http://www.aawsat.net/2011/08/article55245595 FSA Founding Statement] - Asharq al-Awsat web site, accessed 1 October 2013</ref>}} | ||
Is this congruence of name and FSA objectives just coincidence? Is the name's similarity with [[World for Libya]] also just one more coincidence? | Is this congruence of name and FSA objectives just coincidence? Is the name's similarity with [[World for Libya]] also just one more coincidence? | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Opaque Organisation== | ||
| + | [[Image:Imam Mujahed.jpg|right|thumb|Poster claiming trustee status of [[Imam Mujahed]]]] | ||
| + | The organisation of Hand in Hand for Syria is unclear. They have claimed to operate 5 different hospitals and support over 140 makeshift hospitals, but they refuse to give out the addresses of their hospitals.<ref>http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk/what-we-do/faq</ref> | ||
| + | They claim to operate a fleet of 32 ambulances, run a permanent blood bank and to train large numbers of medical workers in the treatment of conflict injuries.<ref>http://todaynewstime.com/syria-charity-blames-red-tape-for-closure-of-aleppo-hospital/</ref> Yet they have never submitted an annual report to the Charity Commission. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Various non-trustees have claimed trustee status. As of 17 August 2014, there were still only 3 trustees (the founders of the group). As [[Declan Hayes]] puts it: | ||
| + | {{QB|Because of its opaqueness, it is hard to ascertain who exactly is in charge of the Hand in Hand for Syria organisation. Although, for example, [[Faddy Sahloul]] is used as the main | ||
| + | contact point on the Charity Commission page, which also lists Razan, his (apparent) wife and [[Fadi al Dairi]] as the only other two trustees, some others, such as accountant [[Marwan Ghannam]] who registered their website (but who is not involved in doing their accounts) also play key roles. Another person who has played a prominent if at times coy role in this group is marble entrepreneur [[Iman Mujahed]]...<ref name="hig">[[File:Hand in Glove.pdf]], by [[Declan Hayes]]</ref>}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Accounting issues== | ||
| + | The group's banking is reportedly done by [[Razan Zehrawi]], a member with a background in decorative arts<ref>http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk/what-we-do/who</ref> rather than [[Marwan Ghannam]], a chartered accountant associated with the group.<ref name="hig"/> Group members estimates of costs have varied wildly. For example, Fadi al-Dairi has claimed that their employees "are paid around £70-80 a month"<ref>http://www.youngperspective.net/delivering-aid-inside-syria.html</ref>, a total wage bill of around £7,500 for the 98 employees of their Atareb hospital. This figure sits uneasily with [[Dr Rola]]’s estimate of its total running costs of $60-70,000 per month. | ||
| + | |||
| + | In spite of repeated claims of painstaking accounting "even down to the antiseptic"<ref>http://edition.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1310/08/ctw.01.html</ref>, the charity has repeatedly breached the UK Charity Commission's rules for filing its accounts every year since it was started: | ||
| + | * 2012 Accounts were filed on 13th August, 2014 (347 days overdue), returns were filed on November 11, 2014 (437 days overdue) | ||
| + | * 2013 Accounts/report were filed on 2nd Apr, 2015 (214 days overdue)<ref name="ccfiling">http://www.charitycommission.gov.uk/detailed-guidance/money-and-accounts/charity-reporting-and-accounting-the-essentials-2009-cc15b</ref> | ||
| + | * 2014 Accounts were filed on 19th January, 2016 (141 days overdue), returns were filed on 21st January, 2016 (143 days overdue) | ||
| + | * 2015 Accounts were not filed by 31st October 2016 (overdue), returns were similarly overdue | ||
| + | [[Fadi Al-Dairi]] suggested that the [[Charity Commission]] was 'Islamophobic' for asking them to submit their accounts.<ref>http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qgJwd48ASy4</ref><ref name="hig"/> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==2014 Appeal== | ||
| + | In 2014, Hand in Hand for Syria launched an appeal for money to equip Atareb Hospital, Aleppo (the hospital from which "[[Dr Rola]]" made her dramatic broadcast). Irregularities have been alleged in this regard, since what is described as "a basic hospital funded by handouts" and "a field hospital" appears in fact to be relatively well-equipped, including a kidney dialysis machine, surgical and x-ray facilities.<ref>http://bbcpanoramasavingsyriaschildren.wordpress.com/2014/06/11/bbc-editorial-complaints-final-report-19-may-2014/</ref> | ||
==Relationship to World For Libya== | ==Relationship to World For Libya== | ||
{{FA|World for Libya}} | {{FA|World for Libya}} | ||
| − | Hand in Hand for Syria has no | + | Hand in Hand for Syria has no acknowledged connection to ''[[World For Libya]]'', a UK charity registered 8 months earlier. However, the parallels are striking:- both sport a logo indicative of a political affiliation to a rebel group, against which the {{ccm}} have proposed [[humanitarian intervention]]. Moreover, both have been assisted by film maker and medic Dr [[Saleyha Ahsan]]. |
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
{{SMWDocs}} | {{SMWDocs}} | ||
| − | |||
==References== | ==References== | ||
{{reflist}} | {{reflist}} | ||
Latest revision as of 17:11, 12 June 2018
"Charity" Hand in Hand for Syria      | |
|---|---|
 | |
| Formation | 2011 |
| Founder | • Faddy Sahloul • Razan Sahloul • Fadi Al-Dairi |
| Type | charity? |
| Interest of | Declan Hayes, Robert Stuart |
| Membership | • Faddy Sahloul • Razan Sahloul • Fadi Al-Dairi • Omar Abdul Gabbar • Nada Alkordi • Razan Zehrawi • Talaat Atassi • Rola Hallam • Raid Atassi • Manhal Alnasser • Basim Rahbi |
| The spooky organisation that "Dr Rola" was working for when she called for humanitarian bombing of Syria. Now renamed and operating also in Turkey and Jordan. | |
Hand in Hand for Aid And Development is a UK registered charity incorporated on 13 February 2012 as Hand in Hand for Syria[1] and its web site was set up on 1 March 2012. Channel 4 reports that it was "formed from within the Syrian diaspora [in 2012] in response to a deteriorating humanitarian crisis in the region"[2]. The organisation came to prominence through "Dr Rola (Hallam)", who was apparently working as a volunteer during an alleged Napalm attack on a school in the village of Orum Alkubra in Aleppo on 26 August 2013.[3] In 2017 it was chosen as "Charity Of The Year" by the Muslim Charities Forum.[4]
Contents
Official Narrative
Their Facebook page described Hand in Hand for Syria as a "UK Registered charity providing humanitarian support for the people of Syria." Their website states that they work wth the "UN’s OCHA (Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Affairs) to plan the distribution of aid."[5] By September 2016, they were working in Jordan, Syria and Turkey.[6]
Problems
According to the UK charity commission, "an organisation cannot be a charity if it has a 'political purpose'."[7] As a UK charity, Hand in Hand for Syria is therefore explicitly prohibited from "furthering the interests of a particular political party" or from "securing or opposing any change in the law, whether in the UK or overseas".[7]
Logo
As in the case of World for Libya, the charity's logo is clearly intended to display a political affiliation. (See the flag of the Syrian National Opposition - right, above). Both supposedly non-political groups aligned themselves with the aims of the rebel groups. In Spring 2014, when their website was updated, the logo was quietly modified to remove the three red stars and the globe, but the affiliation remains indisputable.
Name
In its 29 July 2011 founding statement, Free Syrian Army leader Colonel Riad al-Asaad said:
... We announce the formation of the free Syrian army to work hand in hand with the people to achieve freedom and dignity to bring this regime down, protect the revolution and the country’s resources, and stand in the face of the irresponsible military machine that protects the regime.”[8]
Is this congruence of name and FSA objectives just coincidence? Is the name's similarity with World for Libya also just one more coincidence?
Opaque Organisation
The organisation of Hand in Hand for Syria is unclear. They have claimed to operate 5 different hospitals and support over 140 makeshift hospitals, but they refuse to give out the addresses of their hospitals.[9] They claim to operate a fleet of 32 ambulances, run a permanent blood bank and to train large numbers of medical workers in the treatment of conflict injuries.[10] Yet they have never submitted an annual report to the Charity Commission.
Various non-trustees have claimed trustee status. As of 17 August 2014, there were still only 3 trustees (the founders of the group). As Declan Hayes puts it:
Because of its opaqueness, it is hard to ascertain who exactly is in charge of the Hand in Hand for Syria organisation. Although, for example, Faddy Sahloul is used as the main contact point on the Charity Commission page, which also lists Razan, his (apparent) wife and Fadi al Dairi as the only other two trustees, some others, such as accountant Marwan Ghannam who registered their website (but who is not involved in doing their accounts) also play key roles. Another person who has played a prominent if at times coy role in this group is marble entrepreneur Iman Mujahed...[11]
Accounting issues
The group's banking is reportedly done by Razan Zehrawi, a member with a background in decorative arts[12] rather than Marwan Ghannam, a chartered accountant associated with the group.[11] Group members estimates of costs have varied wildly. For example, Fadi al-Dairi has claimed that their employees "are paid around £70-80 a month"[13], a total wage bill of around £7,500 for the 98 employees of their Atareb hospital. This figure sits uneasily with Dr Rola’s estimate of its total running costs of $60-70,000 per month.
In spite of repeated claims of painstaking accounting "even down to the antiseptic"[14], the charity has repeatedly breached the UK Charity Commission's rules for filing its accounts every year since it was started:
- 2012 Accounts were filed on 13th August, 2014 (347 days overdue), returns were filed on November 11, 2014 (437 days overdue)
- 2013 Accounts/report were filed on 2nd Apr, 2015 (214 days overdue)[15]
- 2014 Accounts were filed on 19th January, 2016 (141 days overdue), returns were filed on 21st January, 2016 (143 days overdue)
- 2015 Accounts were not filed by 31st October 2016 (overdue), returns were similarly overdue
Fadi Al-Dairi suggested that the Charity Commission was 'Islamophobic' for asking them to submit their accounts.[16][11]
2014 Appeal
In 2014, Hand in Hand for Syria launched an appeal for money to equip Atareb Hospital, Aleppo (the hospital from which "Dr Rola" made her dramatic broadcast). Irregularities have been alleged in this regard, since what is described as "a basic hospital funded by handouts" and "a field hospital" appears in fact to be relatively well-equipped, including a kidney dialysis machine, surgical and x-ray facilities.[17]
Relationship to World For Libya
- Full article: World for Libya
- Full article: World for Libya
Hand in Hand for Syria has no acknowledged connection to World For Libya, a UK charity registered 8 months earlier. However, the parallels are striking:- both sport a logo indicative of a political affiliation to a rebel group, against which the commercially-controlled media have proposed humanitarian intervention. Moreover, both have been assisted by film maker and medic Dr Saleyha Ahsan.
Known member
1 of the 11 of the members already have pages here:
| Member |
|---|
| Faddy Sahloul |
Related Document
| Title | Type | Publication date | Author(s) | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| File:Hand in Glove.pdf | report | 23 July 2014 | Declan Hayes | An exploration of the murky truth about "Hand in Hand for Syria", first brought to prominence by the murky "Dr Rola" TV report which appeared designed to stoke support for a 'humanitarian' bombing of Syria. |
References
- ↑ Charity Commission - Statutory information on 'Hand-in-Hand-for-Syria' at 29 June 2014
- ↑ Syria - where medicine is a weapon of war, Channel 4 report of Jan 23, 2013
- ↑ Hand in Hand for Syria - Home page
- ↑ https://www.civilsociety.co.uk/news/hand-in-hand-for-syria-wins-overall-award-at-the-mcf-awards.html
- ↑ http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk/what-we-do/partners
- ↑ http://apps.charitycommission.gov.uk/Showcharity/RegisterOfCharities/PrintReport.aspx?RegisteredCharityNumber=1145862&ReportType=BW%20Charity%20Commission
- ↑ a b UK Charity Commission, What Makes a Charity? Annex B - Political Purposes
- ↑ FSA Founding Statement - Asharq al-Awsat web site, accessed 1 October 2013
- ↑ http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk/what-we-do/faq
- ↑ http://todaynewstime.com/syria-charity-blames-red-tape-for-closure-of-aleppo-hospital/
- ↑ a b c File:Hand in Glove.pdf, by Declan Hayes
- ↑ http://www.handinhandforsyria.org.uk/what-we-do/who
- ↑ http://www.youngperspective.net/delivering-aid-inside-syria.html
- ↑ http://edition.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1310/08/ctw.01.html
- ↑ http://www.charitycommission.gov.uk/detailed-guidance/money-and-accounts/charity-reporting-and-accounting-the-essentials-2009-cc15b
- ↑ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qgJwd48ASy4
- ↑ http://bbcpanoramasavingsyriaschildren.wordpress.com/2014/06/11/bbc-editorial-complaints-final-report-19-may-2014/
