Difference between revisions of "Talk:UK/Torture"

From Wikispooks
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Robin moved page Talk:United Kingdom/Torture to Talk:UK/Torture over redirect: Better as it can be a base page name)
(Added Talk template)
 
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
{{talk}}
 
==Subpage?==
 
==Subpage?==
This relates two different ideas, [[UK]] and [[torture]], but the standard connector ([[WikiSpooks:Standardisation#Subpages|"/", meaning "of"]]) doesn't quite work:
+
This relates two different ideas, [[UK]] and [[torture]], but the standard connector ([[Wikispooks:Standardisation#Subpages|"/", meaning "of"]]) doesn't quite work:
 
* Torture/UK ~ "The UK Of Torture"
 
* Torture/UK ~ "The UK Of Torture"
 
* UK/Torture ~ "Torture of the UK"
 
* UK/Torture ~ "Torture of the UK"
 
Since neither of these makes much sense, they will probably never be needed for another topic, so perhaps the meaning of "/" could be broadened out; how about expanding it to include "by" or "in"...? If this seems like a rather abstract thought, remember that the more closely we can pin down the semantics, the better we can expect {{SMW}} to perform - and pagenames are the base unit of semantic. I think I'll leave the question hanging for a while and look at other such pages, but discussion on this point is welcome. [[User:Robin|Robin]] ([[User talk:Robin|talk]]) 15:31, 11 August 2014 (IST)
 
Since neither of these makes much sense, they will probably never be needed for another topic, so perhaps the meaning of "/" could be broadened out; how about expanding it to include "by" or "in"...? If this seems like a rather abstract thought, remember that the more closely we can pin down the semantics, the better we can expect {{SMW}} to perform - and pagenames are the base unit of semantic. I think I'll leave the question hanging for a while and look at other such pages, but discussion on this point is welcome. [[User:Robin|Robin]] ([[User talk:Robin|talk]]) 15:31, 11 August 2014 (IST)

Latest revision as of 17:22, 14 October 2018

Subpage?

This relates two different ideas, UK and torture, but the standard connector ("/", meaning "of") doesn't quite work:

  • Torture/UK ~ "The UK Of Torture"
  • UK/Torture ~ "Torture of the UK"

Since neither of these makes much sense, they will probably never be needed for another topic, so perhaps the meaning of "/" could be broadened out; how about expanding it to include "by" or "in"...? If this seems like a rather abstract thought, remember that the more closely we can pin down the semantics, the better we can expect SMW to perform - and pagenames are the base unit of semantic. I think I'll leave the question hanging for a while and look at other such pages, but discussion on this point is welcome. Robin (talk) 15:31, 11 August 2014 (IST)