Difference between revisions of "Wikipedia:Omar Khadr"

From Wikispooks
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(New link format)
Line 2: Line 2:
 
|WpPageName=Omar Khadr
 
|WpPageName=Omar Khadr
 
|WpURL=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omar_Khadr
 
|WpURL=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omar_Khadr
|WpIntro=This Wikipedia page is a particularly egregious example of the insidious ''[[Project:Definitions|Official Narrative]]''-supporting nature of [[Wikipedia]]. Anyone visiting that page will immediately be drawn to the photograph and its accompanying caption information. For the casual visitor, if they read anything at all, that is pretty much guaranteed to be it. For everyone else it is likely to be the first impression.  
+
|WpIntro=This Wikipedia page is a particularly egregious example of the insidious ''[[Project:Definitions|Official Narrative]]''-supporting nature of [[Wikipedia]]. Anyone visiting that page will immediately be drawn to the photograph and its accompanying caption information. For the casual visitor, if they read anything at all, that is pretty much guaranteed to be it. Most people will quickly get such an impression without looking deeper.
  
'''In summary the impression is that Khadr is a 24 year old, convicted war criminal and terrorist, and alleged al-Qaeda member.'''. Whilst much of the background to this summary is covered in the rest of what is a detailed article, in most cases that is likely to be the over-riding impression they are left with. i.e. nothing about:
+
'''In summary the impression is that Khadr is a 24 year old, convicted war criminal and terrorist, and alleged al-Qaeda member.'''. Whilst much of the background to this summary ''is'' covered in the rest of what is a detailed article, in most cases that is likely to be the over-riding impression they are left with. i.e. nothing about:
 
*His being 15 years old when his alleged 'Offences' took place
 
*His being 15 years old when his alleged 'Offences' took place
 
*His extended torture and mistreatment over 8 years in mostly solitary confinement
 
*His extended torture and mistreatment over 8 years in mostly solitary confinement
Line 10: Line 10:
 
*The nature of the so-called 'legal process' that prosecuted the alleged offences
 
*The nature of the so-called 'legal process' that prosecuted the alleged offences
 
*The assumption underlying that process: that it was legal for US soldiers to attack and kill Khadr's uncle and others in an ambush in their own country, but that returning fire was illegal
 
*The assumption underlying that process: that it was legal for US soldiers to attack and kill Khadr's uncle and others in an ambush in their own country, but that returning fire was illegal
Much of the above IS contained in the body of the article; but the vast majority of visitors to that page will pigeon-hole Khadr as a ''"convicted terrorist and war criminal"'' and move on.
 
  
 
|WsLink0=Omar Khadr
 
|WsLink0=Omar Khadr

Revision as of 13:47, 7 August 2011


Omar Khadr Omar Khadr
WpIcon32.png Omar Khadr






This Wikipedia page is a particularly egregious example of the insidious Official Narrative-supporting nature of Wikipedia. Anyone visiting that page will immediately be drawn to the photograph and its accompanying caption information. For the casual visitor, if they read anything at all, that is pretty much guaranteed to be it. Most people will quickly get such an impression without looking deeper.

In summary the impression is that Khadr is a 24 year old, convicted war criminal and terrorist, and alleged al-Qaeda member.. Whilst much of the background to this summary is covered in the rest of what is a detailed article, in most cases that is likely to be the over-riding impression they are left with. i.e. nothing about:

  • His being 15 years old when his alleged 'Offences' took place
  • His extended torture and mistreatment over 8 years in mostly solitary confinement
  • The 'plea-bargain' agreement that offered him freedom in a few years if he pleaded guilty; or incarceration for life if he did not
  • The nature of the so-called 'legal process' that prosecuted the alleged offences
  • The assumption underlying that process: that it was legal for US soldiers to attack and kill Khadr's uncle and others in an ambush in their own country, but that returning fire was illegal


Related Wikispooks Pages

Document:Child Soldier Coerced Into Plea-Bargain Document:Child Soldier Coerced Into Plea-Bargain - An article by Keith Jones, published by WSWS on 27 October 2010

External Links